Friday, April 29, 2011

Sheriff Joe Arpaio and the Other Maricopa County Law Enforcement Liars Begin to Fall

Sheriff Joe Arpaio of Maricopa County, America's Toughest Sheriff has been repeatedly outed on Bad Lawyer as a extra-legal law enforcement thug.  He countenanced constitutional abuses by his deputies and he created a reign of terror that has cost and will cost Maricopa County and the State of Arizona millions.  And yet, like the birthers--Arpaio is a darling of the right and Republicans throughout the United States--often flown into to raise money for the Republicans.

Corruption was so rife in Maricopa County that another Arizona County's (Pinal) Sheriff was detailed with conducting an investigations.  When Arpaio received the investigation which confirmed wholesale corruption by his chief deputies he stonewalled media requests to release the report.  The report has now been released and Deputies involved in corrupt and illegal activities are beginning to lose their jobs, including chief deputy David Hendershott.  

Obviously, the question that remains is how long will Arpaio himself be free from federal indictment?  Stay tuned.  At the link, excerpts from the Pinal County Sheriff's investigation.

Deposition Misconduct

Above the Law has this astonishing depostion transcript:


Thursday, April 28, 2011

Serial Fakers


An Associated Press article by Thomas Sheeran at the Columbus Dispatch has the tale of the serial faker, Randall /Thomas Keyser.  Keyser has engaged in outlandish and repeated acts of fraud and fakery.  He's a character right out of Twain's Huckleberry Finn.  Here's the story:

"A man charged with trying to land a six-figure job in Ohio by faking it as an Army general has misrepresented his background in the past, according to court records.  Randall Thomas Keyser, of Barboursville, W.Va., has used seven or more aliases and was hired under false pretenses in Alaska, Florida, Kentucky and Washington state, according to the documents obtained by the Associated Press. The FBI said he has used three Social Security numbers.

The FBI confirmed today that the individual mentioned in the court records is the same man charged in Akron with wire fraud for allegedly posing as a major general.
In a 1993 ruling involving a probation violation, the Court of Appeals of Alaska portrayed Keyser as a serial faker who misrepresented his background to land jobs in the private and public sectors.
'Mr. Keyser has a track record of being `found out' in communities where he has talked himself into employment that he is not qualified for, and then leaving town, sometimes traveling clear across the country,' the court said. 'Without measures being taken to correct that behavior, Mr. Keyser is likely to reoffend.'  That court case stemmed from a probation violation on Keyser's no-contest plea to a theft charge for a fraudulent application to be city manager of Kake, Alaska.  About the same time, he was arrested by Alaska state troopers on a theft by deception warrant stemming from his application to be city manager in Pikeville, Ky. [ . . .]  His probation was transferred to Washington state when he moved to the Seattle area, according to the appeals court, which said he then was involved in getting a number of apartment-management jobs by using forged military records and Social Security cards issued under aliases.

'Keyser's false claims appeared to become increasingly grandiose, almost gratuitously so,' the court said.

At various times, according to the appeals court, Keyser claimed to have graduated from West Point and to have retired with the rank of major or lieutenant colonel.  In reality, Keyser served one or two years in the Army and was discharged as a private, the court said.

Keyser may have obtained 13 jobs as a police officer or police chief in small communities across the nation in the 1980s, the court said, including a chief's job in Oak Hill., Fla., where he was convicted of perjury and got one year of probation.

Prosecutors in Ohio say Keyser applied for a job pretending to be a major general with references including the Army chief of staff, vice chief of staff and Army undersecretary. An FBI affidavit said Keyser sought the $175,000 job and payment for travel expenses for an interview."
___________________________________________________
I wrote about Skyler Smith (pic) last year.  Smith, a Huntsville, Alabama serial con artist was running a variety of scams including the whole fake disabled  military veteran scam as well as selling phony diamonds over the Internet. 

One morning at FCI,Morgantown I was sitting in the chow hall with the usual suspects when a new guy at a nearby table launched into this whole rap about his case.  He wanted to connect with an "inmate lawyer."  The more I listened to him, the more I recognized Skyler Smith from the news account that I posted in September, 2010.  The thing is--Skyler Smith,as with many guys that I met in prison, the whole incarceration-thing does not seem to have had the intended come-to-God effect.  The con artist is still a con artist, the briber is still a briber, the drug addict sits at his bunk and wistfully dreams of a handful of pills.

Fudging Is Another Word for Lying


A lawyer who is a candidate for a municipal court is admitting that he "fudged" the law enforcement endorsements listed in his campaign literature.  This is Joan Rusek's story from the Chagrin-Solon Sun News:

"Republican Chardon Municipal Court candidate Dennis Coyne admitted he 'tried to fudge' endorsements 'a little'  on his campaign literature during an April 19 phone call with Police Chief Jon Bokovitz.  That phone call was recorded, as are five phone lines that go through the Bainbridge police station’s nonemergency line [. . .] Those calls are answered by emergency dispatch operators.
Coyne was returning Bokovitz’s call. Bokovitz had called Coyne after a resident questioned him.
That resident received Coyne’s campaign postcard which states he is 'endorsed and supported by every police chief in Geauga County.'

The [campaign] literature, headlined with 'Honest – Ethical – Experienced,' also states Coyne is endorsed by 'every mayor, every prosecutor and every criminal public defender' in the county.  The resident questioned the endorsement because it has been a long-standing policy for the chief to not endorse candidates and issues other than a Bainbridge police levy.

[Police Chief] Bokovitz said he told Coyne, 'No,' when asked for an endorsement in January.  'There can be hard feelings with other candidates,' Bokovitz said. “Because it falls under political party lines, it can also create hard feelings with residents who belong to a different political party.'  In fact, Bokovitz would have been in an awkward position because one of his bosses, township Trustee Matt Lynch, is also running for the Republican ticket in the May 3 primary election."
____________________________________________
Ms. Rusek's article goes on at some length analyzing Mr. Coyne's rationalizations for lying about his claimed endorsements.

I'm not posting the story about Mr. Coyne to call him a liar, but the Sun News account fits into a couple of overlapping threads from the last couple of days:  the post at Bad Lawyer about the Judge who excluded the testimony and evidence which was supported by claimed expert testimony of an Alaskan State Trooper who said he could smell marijuana "grow operations;" and, the post and commentary at Scott Greenfield's Simple Justice blawg concerning a Las Vegas resident's beating at the hands of a violent cop provoked by the citizen's video recording of the officer involved.  In a larger sense the overlapping discussions relate to official honesty and integrity. 

Late yesterday morning I also heard James B. Stewart discussing (at the link you can listen as well, to Stewart talk about) his latest book, Tangled Webs with WAMU's Diane Rehm.  Stewart discussed high profile liars:  Bill Clinton, George W. Bush, Karl Rove, Scooter Libby, Martha Stewart, track and field star Marion Jones, Barry Bonds' trainer Greg Anderson, and Bernie Madoff.  Stewart provocatively asks about the corrosive effect that our lying.  Mr. Stewart concludes that failure to sanction lying degrades values and institutions and breeds widespread disregard for America and Americans internationally.  Let's go one step forward, (expected) petty lying by lawyers undermines the rule of law, respect for the law, and respect for legal outcomes. 

Personally, all this talk about lying and dishonesty makes me incredibly uncomfortable.  If you put "lying" into the search function of this blawg you will come up with dozens and dozens of posts over the last couple of years about lying cops, prosecutors, lawyers, politicians, judges, witnesses, and me.  This blawg is in many ways a reflection of the struggle on my part to come to grip with my dishonesty and lying.  It's real easy to see it in Clinton, Bush Rove, Madoff, but it's another thing to see the little bits of "fudging."  But fudging is lying.  There should be no place for "fudging" in the law.  That law enforcement and officers of the court are perceived to get away with it--is the problem.  And going forward, for me, there is no room for "fudging." 

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

Further Southern Exposure

Maybe it's that Southern weather but the Legal Profession Blawg had this link to a South Carolina Supreme Court decision suspending a member (intended) for dropping trou.   The lawyer's name is J.M. "Buddy" Long, III, a Conway, SC family law practitioner.  

According to the opinion attorney Long liked to expose himself to passers-by standing behind the storm door of his house sans pants. 

Networking Opportunities

Prison can present networking opportunities.  The New York Daily News leads this yesterday's edition, at least at it's website with the story of "disgraced" former NY State Comptroller Alan Hevesi doing time with former TYCO CEO Dennis Kozlowski at the NY's Mid-State Correctional facility.  This is from reporter Kenneth Lovett's story.

They're the state prison system's high profile Odd Couple: Disgraced ex-Controller Alan Hevesi is serving his time with shamed Tyco CEO Dennis Kozlowski.  The scammers mingle together with 20 other inmates from 6:30 a.m. to 11 p.m. in the protective custody unit at Mid-State Correctional Facility in Oneida County.

Hevesi, 71, landed at the prison late last week to start his one- to four-year stint on a felony corruption charge.  He pleaded guilty to pocketing $1 million in gifts for himself and cronies in a massive pay-to-play pension fund scam.

Kozlowski, 64, is serving up to 25 years in the slammer for his 2005 conviction on grand larceny and securities fraud - ripping off $100 million from his company to support his lavish, jet-set lifestyle.
Hevesi used his ill-gotten gains to fly himself and family to Israel and Italy, while Kozlowski used his to fund a booze-fueled birthday bash in Sardinia for his wife - complete with a replica of Michelangelo's statue of David urinating vodka.

Inmates jointly eat, exercise, attend recreation and education programs and perform prison job assignments all within the boundaries of the protective custody unit.  That likely leaves plenty of time for Hevesi and Kozlowski to kibitz about high finance.

Hevesi, who served as controller from 2003 to 2006, grew New York's investment in Tyco, topping out at 8.3 million shares right before Kozlowski's conviction, state records show. 
____________________________________
At Morgantown there were 1200-1300 inmates at anyone time.  By far the majority of this population were drug-related offenders, but as I said there were many white collar criminals including real estate developers, builders, brokers and former fortune five hundred executives.  Because the inmate population included accountants, financial types, lawyers, and physicians, inmates are able to avail themselves of classes, seminars, and tutorials of all types.  It was not unusual for me, a library dweller, to be "ear-hustling" day trading lessons as one knowledgeable inmate tutored another about commodities, penny stocks, and currency trading.  Networking opportunities to be desired?  No.

Georgia Suspends Overexposed Lawyer

The Above the Law blawg has an ironic feature it calls Lawyer of the Day.  In October of 2007, ATL named Robin Meredith Levin, a former public defender who exposed himself to a 16 year old daughter of friend via webcam.  Ah, social networkind, so useful, eh?

According to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution the Georgia Supreme Court imposed a 24 month suspension.   By the way, the AJC was also the source of the original account relied.  In the new story, the AJC tells us that Levin was a former public defender in Clayton County, Georgia. 

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Ray Towler Spent 29 Years Behind Bars for a Crime He Didn't Commit, Ohio to Pay Him $2.5 Million

Last year I wrote several posts about Ray Towler (pic) the inmate who spent 29 years behind bars for a child rape he did not commit.  Cleveland.com is reporting that Towler has settled with the state of Ohio over his wrongful imprisonment.  Something called the Controlling Board has agreed to pay Towler $2.5 million.

 Towler was sentenced to life in prison for raping an 11 year old girl.  DNA evidence obtained with the assistance of the Ohio Innocence Project.

Monday, April 25, 2011

You Smelled What--Um, Probably Not

An Alaskan State Trooper claims to be able sniff out marijuana grow operations all by himself, that is without the assistance of a trained dog.  A US District Court Judge is dubious.  Here's Lisa Demer's story in the Anchorage Dailly News:

"An Alaska trooper's reported ability to sniff out marijuana grow operations from hundreds of feet away is under attack in federal court.   In a ruling Friday, U.S. District Judge John Sedwick concluded the pot-smelling power of investigator Kyle Young wasn't supported by the facts in a Mat-Su marijuana case, and shouldn't have been used as justification for a search warrant.  As a result, Sedwick threw out the seized evidence -- including some 500 marijuana plants. Unless prosecutors appeal, the government's drug case against Trace Rae and Jennifer Anne Thoms of Wasilla is gutted.

'This time, the tables turned,' defense lawyer Rex Butler, who represents Trace Thoms, said Sunday. 'This is a huge case, especially for the Valley.'  [Attorney Butler] said it carries implications for numerous cases that were based on trooper Young's reputed marijuana-detecting skill.

Young, who has more than 20 years with the troopers, maintains he did smell marijuana that day in February 2010. 'It was fairly strong. Smelled it on the air. Smelled it downwind of that place,' Young said in an interview Sunday. 'For them to rule that I couldn't, to me that says they are saying I am lying or that I was mistaken. And neither was correct.'  He estimated that he's investigated and seized between 100 to 150 Alaska marijuana grow operations since 1998 that he located by smell.

Trace and Jennifer Thoms each face three drug counts, including manufacturing marijuana, as well as a charge of money laundering conspiracy in which they are accused of disguising more than $1 million in marijuana proceeds. In addition, Jennifer Thoms separately faces 14 money laundering counts.  The indictment against them also seeks forfeiture of various properties including their home, nearly $100,000, five snowmachines, a Ford F-250, a GMC Yukon Denali, a Rolex gold watch, and a 14-karat diamond wedding ring set.
THE SMELL TEST
Young, who has advanced training in drug investigations, was assigned to the Alaska Bureau of Alcohol and Drug Enforcement in November 2000.  In his sworn statement supporting his request for a search warrant last year, Young wrote that he was driving on Scarlet Circle -- in a residential area -- around 1:20 a.m. on Feb. 22, 2010, when he smelled 'a strong odor of cultivating marijuana.'  He already had suspicions about a grow operation there, he said in the interview.

[Trooper Young] stopped and determined he was downwind of the first house on the right and that's where the smell was coming from. He checked property records and found that it belonged to Trace and Jennifer Thoms, he wrote in his affidavit. He found that Trace Thoms had a criminal history, including a 2005 felony marijuana conviction. He checked electrical usage and found that the home had two accounts in Jennifer Thoms' name averaging nearly $800 in electricity a month. (Young said he later found out there were additional accounts in the name of businesses for snow plowing and painting, which wouldn't have used electricity.)

The same day, troopers searched the property and found what they call a sizable grow operation with budding plants in an outbuilding behind the house. Among the 500 plants, more than 200 were budding, which Young conceded was perhaps all he could smell, according to Sedwick's order.
Prosecutors argue that the fact so many marijuana plants were seized 'would tend to establish the likelihood that there was a strong odor of marijuana present on that date.'

A magistrate judge, John Roberts, in February held a hearing on the search and last month recommended against throwing out the evidence. But the ultimate decision was Sedwick's.
Young said Sunday he was unaware that Sedwick had ruled against the prosecution.
THE CHALLENGE
The outbuilding was at least 450 feet from the road, where Young said he smelled marijuana from inside his vehicle. The building has no windows. There are two doors, and two garage doors, which were insulated and sealed.  In between the building and the road was a wooded area and the couple's two-story residence, which was on a hill.

At the February hearing, Thoms testified his outbuilding was equipped with a large charcoal air filter designed to capture odor. A fan sucked out the air through the filtration system, which weighed about 100 pounds. Thoms testified that he bought new filters weekly and had a dedicated ladder against the building so he checked it 'constantly,' Sedwick wrote.

A smell expert hired by the defense doubted anyone could have smelled marijuana in that situation.
David Doty, director of the Smell and Taste Center at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, 'ultimately opined that there was a 'zero' probability that Young smelled marijuana as he claimed,'  Sedwick wrote.

The defense paid some $20,000 for the expert, which is more than most defendants could afford, Butler said[.]
____________________________________
As a lawyer in and out of courtrooms over the years I listened to a lot of incredible testimony by police officers purporting to possess various forms of "expertise," for instance the ability to adjudge with accuracy "speeding" from perspectives that seems improbable.  Or situations in which police officers with no specialized training offered expert opinions on collisions that did not witness.  Usually this testimony was accepted into evidence as almost sacrosanct.   You can't imagine how much imagination goes into law enforcement affidavits supporting search and seizures.  Well, maybe now you can.

I'll tell you what--if this was a State Court Judge who had to stand for election or reelection I doubt that the same result would have followed.  I can count on one hand the Judges that I've known over the years who would have had the courage to toss this evidence and still stand for election knowing he or she had just pissed off local law enforcement. 

This Just In: Annals of Deterrence

The Boston Herald is reporting that the trial of former Massachusetts Speaker of the House, Sal DiMasi (pic) is set to get underway in US District Court.  In a triumph for the concept of white collar deterrence, DiMasi is the third Mass House Speaker to be charged and tried on corruption charges.  The charges against DiMasi involve a convoluted bribery sting.