Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Man High On Bath Salts Does Something With a Pygmy Goat?!!!

The Charleston Gazette (West Virginia) reports this morning on the Alum Creek area-man, who while "high on bath salts" killed his neighbor's pygmy goat.  That's when the story gets really strange.  This is reporter Gary Harki's account:

Police say an Alum Creek man high on bath salts killed his neighbor's pygmy goat and that neighbors found him in his bedroom, dressed in a bra and panties, next to the dead animal, said Lt. Bryan Stover of the Kanawha County Sheriff's Department.  Mark Thompson, 19, (pic) of Greenview Road, is charged with animal cruelty after police got a call from a woman who said he stole her goat at about 3:15 a.m. Monday, Stover said.

Lisa Powers said she bought the goat on Friday as a gift to her 4-year-old grandson. They named the male goat Bailey after a female character on the Disney Channel television show 'The Suite Life on Deck.' 'The baby just loved him,' she said.

Powers' nephew, Joshua Pollis, got a call from a neighbor early Monday morning, she said.

'They told him that my goat was wandering around in Mark's house and he'd better come and get it,' she said. 'They called my nephew because he'd been there before.'

Pollis and two women walked into Thompson's house looking for the goat, according to the criminal complaint filed in Kanawha County Magistrate Court.  The three entered the house and made their way to Thompson's bedroom door when Thompson spoke to them, Powers said.

'He told them, 'Don't come in, I'm naked,''Powers said. 'But they opened the door and he was standing there with his pants down. He had on women's clothing and the goat was dead and there was blood everywhere. It was just a scene.' 

[Thompson fled the scene]
Police got a search warrant for the house, and searched the woods for Thompson. They found him several hours later.  Thompson allegedly told police he was on bath salts for about three days.

When police entered the house they found fresh blood near the front door of the bedroom and in Thompson's bedroom to the right of the front door. Inside the bedroom police found the small gray and white goat wearing a pink collar lying dead on the floor, blood coming from its neck, according to the complaint. There was a pornographic magazine photo laying a few feet from the goat, the complaint states.'We know the animal had at least one stab wound,' said Cpl. Sean Snuffer, a detective with the Sheriff's Department. 'They are also searching for signs of sexual trauma.'


Police took the dead animal to a veterinarian for a necropsy, he said.  Police are continuing their investigation. Thompson was arraigned Monday afternoon and taken into custody by Adult Protective Services.

Snuffer said the people in the community where Thompson lives told police they have been concerned about his mental health [.]"
_________________________________
I did not know until yesterday that folks "do" bath salts.  Must be a pretty strange "high" if this story is any indication.  What's remarkable to me was that this dude was doing all these things but when they broke in on him he was so modest he was concerned that he was going to be caught with his pants down. 

Years ago when I first began to work with victims of child sex abuse I'd occasionally come across stories as bizarre and almost unbelievable as this one.  My reaction was frankly disbelief.  And yet, in some situations victims would provide tantalizing evidence--letters mainly, although in one occasion a recorded confrontation between the victims and the adult perpetrators that astonished me.  In several occasions photos of absolutely disgusting and perverse acts surfaced, although nothing on this scale. 

I sympathize with the social workers, law enforcement and others who deal with these things.  I got pretty crazy representing victims arising out of these bizarre and perverse childhoods--oh, and I didn't help myself very much.  You need a lot of support to keep normal, normal.  In fact, I think "normal" is an underrated value.

Blessed Pope John Paul II


Pope John Paul II celebrates Mass, You-Know-Who looks on.
 Yeah, this one gets me. 

How is it that the Vatican rationalizes Beatifying Pope John Paul II?  

Oh, I understand why it's politically correct and popular to move him towards sainthood, but is it appropriate? This is the Pope that reigned from 1978 through 2005, the second longest serving pope.  This is the Pope that presided over the Church's policy of willful blindness to clerical sex abuse and worse vilification of the victims.  This charismatic world figure, capable of so much good and positive, even world-changing presided over the Church that covered up sex crimes against children.

The satirical website, the Onion suggest that Pope John Paul II become the Patron Saint of Ignoring a Problem Until You Die.  Yep.

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Jeffrey Toobin on The Greatest Trial That Never Was



At the link, CNN and New Yorker legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin on the Greatest Trial that Never Was. 

"Yeah, Just Send Over a Check!"


The invaluable Law Profession blawg has the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania's disbarment of Paul Wayne Shoup, an attorney who was working for a tax organization.  According to the opinion, attorney Shoup made a remarkable discovery:  "that the Montgomery County [Maryland] Treasury Office website could be easily searched for companies due tax refunds [...  Attorney Shoup] began stealing the unauthorized real property tax refund checks simply by contacting the Montgomery County Treasury Office and requesting that a refund check be mailed out."

Mr. Shoup stole half a million dollars using this technique.  Nice.

Shoup who paid restitution was subsequently sentenced to 18 months for felony theft.

Alleged Gangster NJ Lawyer Trial Set for October

Ted Sherman at the NJ Star Ledger reports that the long-awaited trial of former high-profile Newark lawyer Paul Bergrin (pic) is now set for October 11, 2011.  What follows is from Sherman's piece on Bergrin: 

Paul Bergrin, the once-prominent Newark lawyer facing charges ranging from murder-for-hire to running of high-end call girl operation, got a new trial date today after a federal appeals court reinstated racketeering charges against him.


Held without bail since his arrest, Bergrin sat impassively in blue prison scrubs and shackles as U.S. District Judge William Martini in Newark said jury selection in the case, long delayed by appeals, would start Oct. 11.

Bergrin, 55, was a former federal prosecutor turned high-profile defense attorney whose clients included entertainers like Queen Latifah and Lil’ Kim, as well as U.S. soldiers accused of war crimes in Iraq.

But in 2009, authorities charged him in a bizarre, sweeping indictment that included accusations of the attempted murder of witnesses, his alleged role in a prostitution ring, mortgage fraud and cocaine distribution.

Prosecutors said Bergrin used his law office like a mob operation. They said he sought to hire a hit man from Chicago to kill at least one witness in a Monmouth County drug case he was handling. He was also charged with conspiring to murder an FBI informant who was supposed to testify against another one of Bergrin’s clients — many of whom were drug dealers and gang members.

Several of those charged with Bergrin have quietly pleaded guilty and implicated him in court proceedings. Last August, another lawyer charged in the case, Thomas Moran, admitted he helped run Bergrin’s operation, which authorities say also involved mortgage fraud and drug-running.  And in October, Vicente Esteves, a Monmouth County cocaine trafficker, pleaded guilty as well and claimed he conspired with Bergrin to murder a witness.  Those cases were not publicized by the U.S. Attorney’s office, generating speculation Moran and Esteves may now be cooperating with the government. The U.S. Attorney’s office has declined to comment about the cases.

Last year, [Judge] Martini dismissed the racketeering charges against Bergrin.

'There is little on the face of the indictment demonstrating relatedness among the varied white-collar frauds and street crimes offered by the government,' Martini wrote, finding the charges were not the work of one coordinated enterprise.  But the U.S. Attorney’s office challenged the ruling and earlier this month, the U.S. 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated the racketeering charges. Bergrin’s attorney, Lawrence S. Lustberg, said he is seeking a review of the decision.
____________________________________
Simple Justice blawger, Scott H. Greenfield commented yesterday at Bad Lawyer on how it is that a federal judge can reasonably reject a plea deal as being too lenient yet remain impartial, a seeming contradiction.  Scott observed that one hoped that the Judge would also remain concerned with governmental overreach in charging a criminal defendant where the Judge found such overreach.  In US v. Bergrin, there is an example of a defendant having the full force and weight of the government come down on him, and a federal judge acting to check charges that go beyond the evidence.  Or so it seems. 

Monday, May 2, 2011

Annals of Social Networking: Don't Be Braggin' About How You're Kickin' It When On Home Confinement

Brent Lamar Davis struck and killed a Charleston, WV motorcyclist last year.  While on home confinement awaiting sentencing, Mr. Davis, (pic) was providing details on exactly how he does his thing.  The victim's family as you might imagine have been keeping a close eye on Mr. Davis and turned the gangsta's posts over to the court.  Here's Cheryl Caswell's story for the Charleston Daily Mail:

"A man who pleaded guilty Monday to hitting a motorcyclist last fall, killing him, has now been arrested and incarcerated for drinking and using drugs while on home confinement.   Brent Lamar Davis, 25, of Charleston was put in South Central Regional Jail the day after his court hearing, after prosecutors received a tip from the victim's family that Davis had referred to those disallowed behaviors on Facebook.

Assistant Prosecutor Dan Holstein said Davis will now remain behind bars until his sentencing in June, and he intends to recommend a prison sentence. He faces a possible two to 10 years for driving under the influence causing death.

Michael Frame, 60, of St. Albans was killed in that accident last Labor Day weekend. Davis, driving a 1997 Ford Crown Victoria on MacCorkle Avenue, struck Frame on his motorcycle at the Montrose Drive intersection. He then abandoned his car and fled the scene. 

The rules of the county home confinement program prohibit the possession or use of controlled substances, narcotics, alcohol and drug paraphernalia.

Frame's daughter, Anita Henson of South Carolina, attended Davis' plea hearing Monday and said afterward she wasn't happy the man was permitted to be on home confinement and feared he could still be using alcohol. When alerted to the Facebook posts, Holstein requested officials investigate and Davis admitted to the drug and alcohol use. In fact, he said he smoked ten joints of marijuana and drank tequila the day before his hearing.

Davis accepted a plea deal from prosecutors, who agreed to drop a charge of leaving the scene of the accident.   In October, Hurricane resident David Michael Haning posted property in Poca assessed at nearly $77,500 for Davis' bond. He was released, but ordered to be on home confinement at his West Side house at 1730 Kemp Ave.    Davis at first said he went to the Liquor Mart on Patrick Street to buy the alcohol, which would also have been a violation of home confinement rules. He later changed that story and said a friend brought the alcohol to him.

Harry Carpenter, chief of the home confinement program, sent a letter to Holstein, saying, 'It is my request that prosecutors request that Mr. Davis' bond be revoked. Due to the serious nature of the crime to which he pled, and the fact that he admits to using not only alcohol but illegal substances, add this to his Facebook postings and it seems that Mr. Davis not only shows no remorse, but clearly does not take the authority of the court and this program seriously.'

Upon a motion from Holstein, Kanawha Circuit Court Judge James Stucky revoked that bond and ordered Davis' incarceration immediately.

Court documents include Davis' Facebook posting within the past week, including:

'Getting ready to go to court hope for the best,' 'On some sh—,' 'Drinkin the pain away lets get it,'  'Getting ready to do this 2-10' and 'Livin life to the fullest.'  Also found on his Facebook page, Holstein said, was a photograph of a hand holding a glass with what appeared to be liquor in it.

Holstein said, 'I was going to recommend prison from the get-go, and I think this adds fuel to that. This makes it pretty clear in my mind that he can't obey court orders.'
_________________________________________
This story has so much to recommend it: social networking obviously, home confinement, alcoholism and drug addiction tragedies, and victim impact.   It goes without saying that the rage the victims family must feel is at a level of intensity that goes beyond words.  But if you need any further proof that alcohol (and drug addiction) is cunning, baffling and powerful look no further than Brandon Lamar Davis.   Here's a guy who had every reason to abstain, but did not or could not.  Not only that but to brag about it online. 

It would be easy to claim that this example is just some stupid gang banger,  But a study from Loyola Health Systems in 2009 indicated that Facebook was cited in 1 out of 5 divorces.  My guess is that that number is now considerably, higher.  On Bad Lawyer in the past year we saw numerous instances where texting, Facebook and other social networking created an evidentiary foundation for all sorts of litigation mayhem for juries, lawyers and judges.

Bad Doctor Plea Deal Rejected by Offended Federal Judge

Mark Taylor reports at the Chicago Sun Times on the rejected plea deal for a notorious "Nose Doctor,:"

"A federal judge Wednesday rejected the plea agreement between prosecutors and Mark Weinberger, the Merrillville doctor charged with 22 counts of health care fraud. U.S. District Judge Philip Simon said the 4-year prison sentence and $366,000 in restitution “does not take into account the criminal conduct” of Weinberger, who also faces 350 medical malpractice lawsuits alleging unnecessary surgery and negligence.  [Jusge] Simon said each of the 22 counts represents a patient whose insurer had been defrauded by Weinberger, who authorities said grossed $27 million and netted $7 million during the period in question.

'The problem I’m having is that I don’t know why the government limited its investigation to the 22 counts,'  Simon said. He said court documents showed Weinberger performed hundreds, perhaps thousands of surgeries.  'We’re now supposed to accept that this is the entire scope of the fraud?' he told Weinberger and a courtroom of attorneys and Weinberger patients in federal court in Hammond.
He said he has too many doubts about whether the agreement adequately reflects the 'seriousness and scope of the case.'

After Simon rejected the plea deal, Weinberger withdrew his guilty plea and the two sides began preparing for a trial. If found guilty, Weinberger would face a maximum of 10 years in prison on each of the 22 counts and a maximum fine of $5.5 million. In the rejected deal, Weinberger had admitted billing for procedures he did not perform and agreed not to bill federal health programs again. He also agreed to surrender any profits from magazine, movie, TV or book deals until he had paid all restitution.

Throughout the hearing Weinberger, who was dressed in an orange, short-sleeved prison jumpsuit and white T-shirt with slicked-back hair, followed Simon’s words intently. He barely spoke except to agree to withdraw his guilty plea and was quickly hustled from the courtroom after Simon left.

Valparaiso attorney Kenneth Allen, who won a $13 million civil verdict against Weinberger earlier this year, was happy Simon rejected the plea agreement. Allen said the ear, nose and throat specialist deserves greater punishment. 'He needs not to treat any more patients for the rest of his life,' Allen said. 'Without question, he would harm patients again.'

A Hammond jury found Weinberger at fault in the wrongful death of Phyllis Barnes, Hood’s sister and Shawn Barnes’ mother, and said he failed to diagnose the cancer that claimed her life at age 50 in 2004.  Hood said she was pleased by Simon’s decision. 'I feel like it’s being treated now with the seriousness it deserves,' Hood said. 'Four years was a slap in the face.'

Weinberger fled the country in 2004 facing hundreds of medical malpractice lawsuits and government investigators. He vanished in Europe and was an international fugitive until he was found camping in the foothills of the Italian Alps in 2009.  Weinberger’s saga will be the subject of an episode of the TV show 'American Greed' May 4.
________________________________________
At FCI, Morgantown there were at least a dozen physicians. 

I've already written about Dr. Roger Pellmann, he was the exception to the rule--most of the doctors were incarcerated in connection with Medicare fraud or for criminal roles they played in pill mills. The docs organized themselves into a local medical association and conducted weekly seminars for one another on issues in their respective specialties.   While each of the doctors generously gave their time to other inmates they did not practice medicine.  One of the inmate doctors, Randy, was originally at an FCI near Atlanta, GA close to his home.  While there another inmate collapsed and died.  Randy spent an hour or more attempting to keep the inmate alive through chest compressions.  Afterwards the BOP thanked Doctor Randy, and shipped him to Morgantown.   Incarcerated doctors don't practice medicine, and incarcerated lawyers don't practice law.  Violate this rule and there is an unpleasant consequence. 

In my case, my locker and paperwork drew unusual scrutiny from the authorities.  For awhile it appeared as if my locker and papers were being rifled weekly.  My white collar cohorts suspected that the flurry of pro se filings coming from Carlson unit were being attributed by BOP to my presence.  This was absurd since I know less than nothing about criminal defense law, and I was not interested in opening up a Morgantown practice.   It was BOP paranoia.

The story about Dr. Weinberger was striking from the standpoint of the Judge Simon's actions.  Yeah, I know a federal judge is in no way obligated to accept a plea bargain, but it does seem that Judge Simon is stepping out of his judicial role and into the shoes of the US Attorney.  Judge Simon's critique certainly sounds like the Judge has (impermissibly?) pre-judged the guilt of Dr. Weinberger (who sounds like a real piece of work...)  It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Addiction, Strange Twists of Thinking, and Tikkun

The Ohio State Buckeyes under the late-Woody Hayes featured the stand out quarterback Art Schlichter (pronounced, Sh-lees-ter);  in fact, Schlichter threw the interception that prompted Woody Hayes assault on Clemson linebacker Charlie Bauman in the 1978 gator Bowl game leading to Hayes' dismissal.

Schlichter is a remarkable example of someone so addicted to gambling that it destroyed his career and his life.   The Columbus Dispatch is reporting that Schlichter is again under indictment on 13 felony counts relating to a ticket selling scheme and fraud.  Schlichter is blaming his addiction (on gambling?)  Here's an excerpt from reporter Mike Wagner's report:

"Art Schlichter, the former Ohio State quarterback and one of the nation's most notorious compulsive gamblers, was indicted today on 13 felony counts in connection with the ticket-selling scheme that swindled people out of more than $1 million.

A grand jury handed up the indictment to the Franklin County Prosecutor's office after Schlichter and Prosecutor Ron O'Brien failed to reach a plea agreement since Schlichter surrendered to authorities more than two months ago.

The most serious charge filed against Schlichter includes one rooted in the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, which alleges a pattern of corrupt activity and is typically used to prosecute organized crime. The RICO charge involves Schlichter and five associates, who are not named in the indictment, and accuses them of scamming people out of their financial assets beginning in 2009 and continuing for more than 18 months. In some cases, the schemes involved cash accounts, credit cards, loans and other investments.

Schlichter, 51, an All-American at OSU more than 30 years ago, continues to be held in the Franklin County jail. If convicted on the charges, Schlichter could face a maximum of 30 years in prison.

In each of the 12 felony theft counts, Schlichter is accused of deceiving people and stealing from them. Schlichter is accused of telling people that he could make money by selling tickets to Ohio State football games and the Super Bowl. But in many cases, those who lent him money were never repaid, and others did not receive the tickets they were promised. The indictment also contains an allegation that Schlichter sold memorabilia that had already been sold years ago."
________________________________________
You'll notice that one of the elements of the story is the selling of memorabilia.  In the scandals swirling around Coach Jim Tressel are allegations that Tressel covered up for Ohio State players who were selling memorabilia or exchanging memorabilia for tattoos from tattoo parlor operator who was under investigation by the FBI.  Instead of Tressel reporting the violations by his players to the NCAA as he is obligated to do, he lied. 

There it is again, misplaced values.

These strange twists of thinking can be indicative of a severe addiction as in Schlichter's case, or of a fundamental life correction or redemption.   These flaws, failure and falls of mankind effect me profoundly.  Of course I see myself in them and I am striving mightily to effect my tikkun, my correction.  It's why I write Bad Lawyer.  Bearing in mind that in classic Kabbalah mysticism, the Tikkun ha-Olam is the command that humanity must restore and redeem a broken and fallen world. 

Saturday, April 30, 2011

Loyalty: The Vexing Virtue; also, Why the Bad Lawyer Went to the Hole

Loyalty: The Vexing Virtue (2011, Simon & Schuster), a new book by Eric Felten, was the subject of Diane Rehms' wonderful WAMU and NPR program Thursday which at the link you can listen to for yourself.  The program was a nice follow-up on Diane's interview of James B. Stewart which I just blogged about and provided a similar link to. 
Both new books and interviews deal with the problem of lying which Stewart condemns and Felten explains.  Stewart actually addressed elevation of misplaced loyalty in connection with Greg Anderson, Barry Bonds' trainer who (unlike Floyd Landis) remained silent throughout the criminal prosecutions connected to the Balco and steroid scandals.  Anderson was jailed for contempt of court.  According to James Stewart, at one point when Anderson was released from the federal penitentiary other inmates stood and applauded Anderson's loyalty to Bonds, the sport's cheat.  Stewart points out in the Diane Rehm interview that this is an elevation of prison core values--in other words misplaced loyalty over truth. 

The virtue of loyalty, obviously played itself out (and continues to play itself out) in New Orleans in the wake of Hurricane Katrina with the murder of African-Americans residents by New Orleans' cops and the cover-up by the so-called thin blue line.  Of course, this recurs again and again through-out history, for instance, the NYC police corruption scandals uncovered by the Knapp Commission lay at the heart of the true 1973 Sidney Lumet movie, Serpico.  Don't snitch.  Cops and criminals don't snitch. 

I Go to the HOLE

The HOLE in federal and most state institutions is formally called the Special Housing Unit or informally, the SHU (pronounced like footwear.)  At Morgantown the SHU is a totally secure stand alone structure in blond brick with a red aluminum crown topped by bright stainless razor wire.  Friends of mine ironically call it the red roof inn.  FCI, Morgantown is a minimum security prison "camp" except for the maximum security SHU.  The SHU is where you go if you become subject to disciplinary segregation or in some other way, become a housing issue.  As an inmate, the SHU/HOLE is the last place you want to go.

This is because incarceration in the SHU/HOLE is twenty-four hour a day lock down in a "one" or "two man cells."  In "two-men" cells, you and your bunkee work out how to shit and share the stainless steel toilet and sink a couple of feet from the bunks.  A little sliver of window on the steel door allows you to see a foot or two in each direction, a sliver of window on the opposite side allows you discern some reflected light through the razor wire.  Inmates without a radio have no idea what time of day or night it is except for meals being slid through a slot on the door.  The barely edible offerings from the chow hall are reduced to fully-vile via the method of sitting in covered trays that effectively give every item on the tray a steam bath, so that for instance-bread slices are reduced to wet wash rag-texture. 

If you're housed in the SHU/HOLE in anything besides the coldest days of winter you are supposed to get 1 hour of rec per day on a postage stamp sized exercise yard.  Imagine, however, that it is coldest days of January and in your cell you are already chilled to the bone.  Your feet are in thin canvas tennis shoe flats do you take the hour to walk around outside knowing that once outside you are not allowed back in until the hour has expired?  Also when you're in the SHU if the cell door opens for any reason you are cuffed up from behind through the slot where your food, paper, or mail if any is also handed to you.  Every other day you have the opportunity to shower which entails this cuffing movement to a shower cell and uncuffing.  This is the highlight of every two days in the SHU/HOLE except for weekends, there is no shower on the weekend.

I went to the SHU/HOLE because I witnessed and reported the sexual assault upon my bunkee, a Chinese kid from DC by a Latin King drug dealer from Chicago.  I was at Morgantown two weeks when for the second or third time I watched "Ruiz Chavez" (not his real name) aggressively come onto my bunkee, "Pang" (not his real name.)  Chavez told Pang that he wanted to "enter [him] and [Pang] to have his babies."  The problem was that this "joke" behavior was, over the course of two weeks that I witnessed it--becoming more aggressive and beginning to involve touching Pang on his buttocks and grabbing at him in a way that if it happened to me I'd call the police.  Amazed that no one was saying anything, I started asking guys what the hell they thought was going on.  A couple of guys confirmed for me that Chavez had done similar things to them, one guy Kelvin (not his real name) said Chavez had touched his groin and that he wanted "guys to submit anonymous 'cop outs' to the lieutenant."  A cop out is a inmate request form.

When Chavez repeated an assault on Pang on December 29 of last year I put a signed "cop out" in describing in detail what I saw.  I was paged over the public address system and ordered to go to the lieutenant's office.  There Lieutenant Shaw cross-examined me in a manner that conveyed the lieutenant's pre-judgment that I was naive and oversensitive to the ways of the inmates.  This impression was someone dispelled by my answer to the questions:  Where are you from?  What did you do for a living?  Unbeknownst to the lieutenant I worked on two occasions as a summer intern at a federal prison camp and a medium security federal prison in the 1978 and 1979.  Nonetheless Lieutenant Shaw assured me that he knew this Chavez who he termed a problem that he would address informally in an effort to avoid sending me and Chavez to the SHU/HOLE together.  Shaw then paged Chavez who was informed, according to Chavez that inmates in the bunk wing were snitching him out.  Chavez then spent the next few days threatening and following inmates he suspected of snitching him out; especially, his victim Pang.  I felt that instead of solving a problem for Pang I had created an additional problem.

I sent a second cop out to the Warden, this time complaining that not only was I threatened by Lieutenant Shaw with the SHU, but that the way my original cop out was handled I had created a threatening environment for the Carlson inmates that I resided with because Chavez was accusing others of "snitching' him out.  Monday, January 3d I was sitting in the library when I heard my name and Chavez's called over the Public Address system demanding that we go to the lieutenant's office.  As you might imagine any anonymity I had previously enjoyed as the source of the complaint about Chavez's sexual assaults on Pang disappeared with that joint announcement.  I was briefly cross-examined by a Captain King who wanted to know whether I was "lying" about all the "hearsay" I included in my detailed cop out.  Sounding very much like Robespierre Captain King told one of her lieutenants, "Take him to the SHU!"

As I was marched to the SHU, hands cuffed behind my back the lieutenant informed me that I had in record time "fucked up" paradise, Morgantown being one of the "best places on the FORBES listing of prisons to do time."  Forty-eight hours later this same lieutenant informed me that his investigation revealed that if anything my report understated the degree of problems created by Chavez.  He also acknowledged that after reading my PSI (pre-sentence investigation) I knew more about sexual harassment and sex crimes than any official at Morgantown.  He also told me that he couldn't understand how Chavez's conduct was tolerated non-violently once it came to light what had been going on.  The lieutenant was conciliatory and assured me that he hoped to have me released that very afternoon which was Wednesday, January 5th  In fact I was in the SHU for 6 more calendar days.  Apparently a still angry Captain overruled her investigator.

As you might imagine, going to the SHU was traumatic.  My family did not know where I was and my ability to communicate with them was limited to mail, oh, I did get one phone call which I made on a portable phone rolled up to the cell door with me reaching through the slot.  Unfortunately I reached my very distracted daughter then tending my new, days-old grandson.  It was not until my letters caught up with my wife almost at the time I was released that she understood what happened.  When I wen to the SHU I was stripped and cavity searched.  I was given over-sized orange coveralls and green tinted underwear.  The little bits of property I was beginning to assemble were trashed by the COs who showed up at my locker in Carlson and "packed me out." I was put in a two-man cell with a young guy, Jason, a Chaldean kid from Detroit.  Poor Jason had been in the SHU since New Year's Day when he was observed by Lieutenant Shaw waving at his kids as he left the visiting room.  For this and other offenses Jason spent 31 days in the SHU. 

Life in the SHU/HOLE is as you might imagine, pretty horrible.  I mentioned the toilet, the lack of recreation,  the vile food (with no calorie burning activity I lost 5lbs in 8 days,) but the worst is the endless days and nights.  If you sleep all day you will not sleep at night, but what do you do?  Fortunately, the prison psychologist, rightfully concerned about my mental health, slid my Alcoholics Anonymous text through to me.  I wrote letters with the stubby little flexible pen given me.  Paperbacks from a library cart were handed out.  I was able to knock out about 800 pages of pulp per day.  As I was given a book, I'd beg extras.  Since the authorities would only give me two at a time, I'd collect two for my bunkee who did not read, that way--even in the SHU I was working my book addiction.  In all seriousness, I do not wish the SHU on anyone--including Chavez, who I personally saw as a seriously disturbed person who needed intensive mental health intervention.  I don't think he's a homosexual, he was an opportunistic predator looking for a chance to victimize others.

Chavez went to the SHU (I could hear him but I did not see him and) he did not reemerge from the SHU during the duration of my stay at Morgantown.  Why Chavez was at Morgantown eludes me.  While in the residential units he was strange, scary and dangerous.  Carlson residents suspected him of being the "mad shitter" some one who threw his feces around the toilet areas.  In the showers and his bunk he'd moan and groan for hours on end.  The authorities had already removed him from at least one unit because of disciplinary problems.  At Carlson he would stomp around the circumference of his upper bunk screaming, "I'm the devil, I'm evil, I want to kill you."  When last I heard Chavez was slated to released to hometown Chicago in May.  Good luck, Chicago. 

The official fig leaf justifying my incarceration in the HOLE was that I was being "protected."  How uprooting an inmate from their social supports, eliminating the ability to routinely communicate with their family on the outside, trashing the inmate's property, and thrusting them in the HOLE/SHU with the perpetrator of a sexual assault in a manner that clearly communicates to the inmate population that the witness "snitched out" the perpetrator--operates to "protect" the inmate is a mystery to me.  That is precisely what the authorities did to me. 

And this then is the connection to the elevation of prison core values.  You see, I contravened the inmate value by reporting Chavez's sexual assault on Pang--the authorities knew this although they compounded the problem by leaving no doubt that I was the source of the report by associating both our names in the public address call to the lieutenant's office on January 3d. So even though what Chavez did was obnoxious, criminal, violating a little statute called PREA (the Prison Rape Enforcement ACT)--my act in reporting was viewed as a more problematic and potentially more "dangerous."  And while I was seriously in no danger whatsoever at any point (except, perhaps from Chavez, himself) I was ostracized to some degree by many of my former bunkees.  Frankly, like big deal--I wasn't planning on post-prison networking with any of them.   For the most part, whatever iciness I felt upon my return to Carlson after my 8-day ordeal in the SHU/HOLE dissipated pretty quickly with many guys thanking me for "taking the bullet."  And, yet on the morning I waited to walk out of Morgantown an inmate danced around mocking me for "snitching out Chavez." 
_______________________________
It's jail.  My best thinking got me jail, FCI, Morgantown, and the SHU.  But, I do not share prison values.  I went to the SHU, because I do not misplace loyalty.

Friday, April 29, 2011

How Lawyers Lose Their Mind, Another Deposition Transcript: Photocopier?

This is from a deposition transcript taken by David Marburger, a partner at Baker & Hostettler in a public records case.  The deponee, Lawerence Pattterson is an employee of the Cuyahoga County Information technology office.  He is represented by attorney Matthew Cavanagh:

Marburger: During your tenure in the computer department at the Recorder's office, has the Recorder's office had photocopying machines?

Cavanagh: Objection.

Marburger: Any photocopying machine?

Patterson: When you say "photocopying machine," what do you mean?

Marburger: Let me be -- let me make sure I understand your question. You don't have an understanding of what a photocopying machine is?

Patterson: No. I want to make sure that I answer your question correctly.

Cavanagh: Dave, I'll object to the tone of the question. You make it sound like it's unbelievable to you that he wouldn't know what the definition of a photocopy machine is.

Marburger: I didn't ask him to define it. I asked him if he had any.

Patterson: When you say "photocopying machine," what do you mean?

Marburger: Let me be clear. The term "photocopying machine" is so ambiguous that you can't picture in your mind what a photocopying machine is in an office setting?

Patterson: I just want to make sure I answer your question correctly.

Marburger: Well, we'll find out. If you can say yes or no, I can do follow-ups, but it seems -- if you really don't know in an office setting what a photocopying machine is, I'd like the Ohio Supreme Court to hear you say so.

Patterson: I just want to make sure I answer your question correctly.
 
Cavanagh: There's different types of photocopiers, Dave.

Marburger: You're speaking instead of -- you [the attorney for the County are] not under oath.  [Mr. Patterson] is.

Cavanagh: I understand that, but I understand what his objection is. You want him to answer the question, but I don't think it's fair.

Marburger: [questioningly] It's not fair?

Cavanagh: It's not a fair question. A photocopy machine can be a machine that uses photostatic technology, that uses xerographic technology, that uses scanning technology.

Marburger: I don't care what kind of technology it uses. Has your offices -- we don't have technocrats on the Ohio Supreme Court. We've got people like me, general guys --

Cavanagh: Objection.
Marburger: -- or gals. I'm not really very interested in what the technology element of it is. I want to know --

Cavanagh: That's what's at issue in the case, Dave.

Marburger: Not in my judgment. Do you have photocopying machines at the Recorder's office? If you don't know what that means in an office setting, please tell the court you don't know what it means in an office setting to have a photocopying machine.

Patterson: I would like to answer your question to the best of my ability.
 
Marburger: I'm asking you to answer that.

Patterson: So if you could explain to me what you mean by --

Marburger: I'm not going to do that because I want you -- I want to establish on the record that you really don't know what it is. I want to establish that.   Now, do you know what it is or do you not know what it is? Do you understand what that term means in common parlance or not?

Patterson: Common parlance?

Marburger: Common language.

Patterson: I'm sorry. I didn't know what that meant. I understand that there are photocopying machines, and there are different types of them just like --

Marburger: Are there any in the Recorder's office?

Patterson: -- there are different cars. Some of them run under gas power, some of them under electric power, and I'm asking if you could help me out by explaining what you mean by 'photocopying machines' --

Marburger: That's a great point.

Patterson: -- instead of trying to make me feel stupid.

Marburger: If you feel stupid, it's not because I'm making you feel that way.

Cavanagh: Objection.

Patterson: I have self-confidence and I have no problem.

Marburger: I don't think you're stupid.

Patterson: I think -- I don't have any problem answering the question.

Marburger: I think you're playing games with me.

Cavanagh: Dave, the word 'photocopying' is at issue in this case, and you're asking him whether something is or isn't a photocopy machine, which is a legal conclusion --

Marburger: This isn't a patent case. There's no statute that defines -- where I'm asking him to define technology for me. I'm asking -- I want to find out from a layperson's perspective, not an engineer's perspective, not a technician's perspective, but from -- I have an idea.

Marburger: How about this: Have you ever heard the term 'photocopier' or 'photocopy' used in the Recorder's office by anybody?

Patterson: Photocopy? I'm sure in the time I've been there someone has used the term.

Marburger: And have you ever heard them use it in referencing a particular device or machine within the Recorder's office? By way of example, 'can you photocopy that for me?' That's an example of office parlance.

Patterson: That particular terminology I've not witnessed.

Marburger: What was the context that you've heard the term 'photocopy' used in the Recorder's office?
 
Patterson: I'm sure it's been used. I didn't say I remembered a specific instance.

Marburger: All right. But you have a general understanding that people have used the term 'photocopy' within the Recorder's office in terms of something that could be done there; is that true?

Patterson: I'm sure it's been used. I don't remember a specific instance or how it was used. I'm sure it's been used.

Marburger: And is it fair to say that it's been used in terms of being able to copy one piece of paper onto another piece of paper using a machine? No? Not sure of that?

Patterson: I'm sure it's been used. I don't recall a specific instance in which it was.

Marburger: Do you have a secretary?

Patterson: No.

Marburger: Does anybody there have a secretary?

Patterson: Yes.

Marburger: Have you ever heard a secretary use the term 'photocopy?'
 
Patterson: No.

Marburger: Have you ever-- do you have machines there where I can put in a paper document, push a button or two, and out will come copies of that paper document also on paper? Do you have such a machine?

Patterson: Yes, sir.

Marburger: What do you call that machine?

Patterson: Xerox.

Marburger: Xerox. Is the machine made by the Xerox Company? Is that why it's called Xerox?

Patterson: No.

Marburger: So Xerox, in the parlance that you've described, the language that you've described, is being used generically as opposed to describing a particular brand; is that right?

Patterson: All of my life I've just known people to say Xerox. It's not commonplace to use the terminology that you're using.

Marburger: You mean it's more -- people say Xerox instead of photocopy?

Patterson: If you're referring to a type of machine where you place a piece of paper on the top and press a button and out comes copies of it, they usually refer to it as a Xerox.

Marburger: Have you ever heard it referred to as photocopying?

Patterson: Not with my generation, no.