Monday, May 9, 2011

Even with a Judge on the Jury, the Jury can Hang

Unusual story from the Columbus Dispatch this morning about a hung jury in the trial of an Ohio motorist in the the death of cyclist--turns out that the jury that could not reach a verdict included a state court judge.  This is from reporter John Futty's account:

Judge Glaeden
"Courtroom observers were surprised when a Franklin County judge wound up as a juror in the case of a man accused of killing a bicyclist in Hilliard.  So was the judge, Carrie E. Glaeden.

'No, not at all,' she said when asked if she expected to be seated during the jury-selection process in late March. 'By and large, the thinking is you don't want someone with a legal background on a jury. You don't want someone with outside knowledge.'

But neither the prosecution nor the defense used a challenge to excuse her, and she became the first alternate for the Common Pleas jury. As the trial stretched into a second week, one of the jurors was excused because of a scheduling conflict, and Glaeden took her seat.


The jury deliberated for nearly 12 hours after hearing seven days of testimony but was unable to reach a verdict on either count against Edward Scott Miller, charged with causing the death of bicyclist Steven Barbour by driving recklessly and while impaired by alcohol.

Glaeden, a Municipal Court judge for seven years, wouldn't discuss how she voted or why jurors became deadlocked because the case is to be retried in June. But she said she declined a suggestion that she serve as forewoman and tried to blend in with the rest of the jury.  'I made a good effort, and I think I succeeded in not taking more of a role than being an equal member of the 12,' she said. 'I didn't try to assert myself. ... There were 11 other strong, independent jurors.'

Miller's attorney, D. Timothy Huey, said a major concern about judges sitting on juries is that their opinion will be seen by other jurors as carrying more weight.  'Hypothetically, you want every juror's vote to count equally,' he said.  For Miller's trial, a particularly emotional case, Huey said it made sense to include on the jury a judge who 'is able to set aside the natural sympathies that people might have toward one side or the other. A judge is better able to be a true finder of fact, rather than be swayed by emotion.'

At least two other sitting judges in Franklin County have served on juries during their time on the bench. Domestic Relations Judge James W. Mason served on a Common Pleas jury in a rape and kidnapping case in 2000. Municipal Judge H. William Pollitt Jr. sat on a Common Pleas jury in a burglary case in 2001.  In both cases, the juries acquitted the defendant.  Like Glaeden, both judges were surprised to be seated on a jury.

'I thought either the prosecution or the defense would give me the boot,' Pollitt said.

Mason said he turned down an offer to serve as foreman to avoid the perception that he 'exerted undue influence' over his fellow jurors. But he conceded that he 'gently led the jury to the right conclusion' in returning not-guilty verdicts for a man accused of raping a live-in girlfriend.

Pollitt said he also refused to serve as foreman.  'I didn't want to run the show,' he said. 'But frankly, you know the other jurors are going to defer to you. A lot of them are going to follow your lead.'  Pollitt speculated that, in most cases, the defense attorney would be more reluctant than the prosecutor to place a judge on a jury in a criminal case.

But defense attorney Lou Friscoe, whose client was acquitted by the jury that included Mason, said 'it depends on the judge and the facts.'  He said the rape case essentially was a domestic dispute about sex between two people who lived together, so he thought it made sense to include a domestic-relations judge on the jury.  As a member of the Ohio House, Mason served as chairman of the Judiciary Committee and sponsored legislation that in 1998 eliminated an automatic exemption from jury duty for public officials, including judges.

'I've practiced law as a lawyer, taught law at Capital University, made law as a legislator and enforced laws as a judge,'  Mason said. 'I had done everything but serve on a jury, and I assumed I never would.'
Glaeden said she has served as 'a jury of one' on more than 250 cases in her courtroom for minor-misdemeanor offenses or when defendants waived their right to a jury.  'When I'm a lone juror, I have to make all the decisions myself,'  she said. While serving on the Miller jury, 'it was nice to have 11 other people to confer with.'"
___________________________
A few years ago, the BSL (Blond Super Lawyer) a prominent OurState Labor and Employment (defense)counsel was seated on a high profile case involving allegations of breach of contract and counterclaims of corruption, forgery and embezzlement by the former director of the metropolitan housing authority.  We were surprised when she was not excused from this panel.  Ultimately she was selected by her fellow jurors as the foreperson.  That jury awarded hundreds of thousands of dollars on the counterclaim against the plaintiff, the former director of metropolitan housing.  Evidence and testimony offered at the trial resulted in criminal charges against the plaintiff and one of her witnesses, a fake hand-writing expert.  The hand-writing expert killed himself in the wake of his indictment.

Nailing the Dude: Criminal Prosecution of Sports Heroes

At the end of last week, news reports carried the story of the indictment of baseball legend Lenny "Nails" aka the "Dude" Dykstra (pic) the former Mets and Phillies outfielder.  With Dykstra batting in the lead-off spot, the 1986 Mets coasted to the division crown, outlasting the Phillies by 21 games, en route to a 108–54 season. The Mets made it to the World Series after a hard-fought victory over the National League West Champs Houston Astros in the NLCS.  Dykstra will forever be remembered for his walk off home run in Game 3, which is considered one of the biggest hits in Mets franchise history and the definitive moment of Dykstra's career. Dykstra would bat .304 in the 1986 NLCS and later hit .296 in the World Series against the BoSox. However, it was Dykstra's lead off home run in Game 3 of the World Series at Fenway that served as the spark for a Mets team that had fallen behind 2 games to none.  Following Dykstra's home run, the Mets rallied to defeat the Red Sox in seven games in one of the most memorable World Series of all time.

Dykstra went onto to a brilliant career with the Mets and then the Phillies retiring in 1996 except for a Spring Training comeback abandoned in 1998.  Off the field, Dykstra's business acumen and personal conduct repeatedly brought him to the attention of the authorities.  He was arrested by U.S. Marshals and it is said that he'll be prosecuted by the feds for bankruptcy fraud.  This is the LA Times account:

"Former baseball star Lenny Dykstra was indicted by a federal grand jury Friday on charges including bankruptcy fraud and obstruction of justice, for allegedly sneaking away more than $400,000 in property that should have gone to his creditors, then lying about it under oath.  Dykstra, 48, a former Mets and Phillies outfielder known to his fans by the nickname “Nails,” is accused of stealing, hiding and destroying items such as chandeliers, artwork, sconces and sports memorabilia about himself from his $18-million Ventura County mansion, according to the indictment.  He later filed declarations under oath and lied in bankruptcy court about having received money from selling off the items, the indictment alleged.

Dykstra’s attorney, Mark Werksman, accused the government late Friday of 'using an indictment to punish a debtor,' and said the criminal charges were 'heavy-handed and overbearing.  This is payback by the U.S. government to Lenny Dykstra’s resistance to the trustee’s dismantling of his property and assets in the bankruptcy,'  Werksman said. 'When all the facts come out, we’ll show that Mr. Dykstra acted in good faith and behaved properly.'

If convicted of all 13 counts in the indictment, Dykstra could face a maximum of 80 years in prison, according to the U.S. attorney’s office.  Dykstra, who fashioned himself as a financial guru and entrepreneur after retiring from his baseball career, filed for bankruptcy protection in July 2009 when business ventures started failing and debt began piling up. He was soon pushed into court-ordered liquidation by his creditors.

Bankruptcy trustee Peter C. Anderson called Dykstra’s alleged crimes 'an egregious abuse of the bankruptcy system,' and said they would 'not be tolerated,'  according to a statement released by prosecutors. Dykstra’s bankruptcy case remains pending."
_____________________________

Lance in Maglia Rosa
 As many followers of this blawg know, the Bad Lawyer is an avid fan of professional road cycling and an amateur cyclist himself.  The Giro d' Italia (tour of Italy) began it's 3 week round-about Italy.  I follow this wonderful bike race every year--until realtime coverage came along online, I ordered VHS tapes, and subsequently DVDs (usually arriving months after the race was complete.)  But the delay to see this race, even when the outcome was known was almost always be worth the wait.  In recent years each edition of the Giro featured some drug or cheating scandal effecting the outcome and careers of the participants and race teams.  I believe I wrote about the cheating scandals and ultimately the premature death of the great Italian cyclist, Marco Pantani, Il Pirata.

Largely because of the astounding physical demands on the cyclist, professional bicycle racing is the breeding-ground for all sorts of cheating.  Now, with the confession of cycling cheat and liar, Floyd Landis, many of us who follow cycling are waiting for the indictment (or, perhaps the decision not to pursue charges) against Lance Armstrong.  Some well-placed observers believe that federal charges of wire and mail fraud are imminent.  Allegations against Armstrong relate to hundreds of millions of dollars perhaps involving his ubiquitous Livestrong Cancer foundation  with its iconic rubber yellow bracelet.  The bottom line is the accusation that Lance Armstrong was a "doper," fraud, and perjurer--that millions of dollars changed hands from sponsors and insurance carriers relying on the material representation that Armstrong rode clean. 

Prosecutions of our sports heroes fall into several categories.  There are the offenses connected to the sports performance:  "blood doping" or steroids.  There's sports betting, for example Pete Rose.  Recently there are revelations of sports cheating, gambling and fixing in Sumo wrestling and international cricket matches.  Then there are the non-sports offenses which can be neatly divided into criminal conduct during the playing years and criminal conduct after retirement.  In addition to the drunken and drug-fueled episodes,  there's domestic violence, and sexual misconduct.   Then, there are the financial crimes in which we see guys like Art Schlichter, and now Lenny Dykstra. 

Sports gives men and women who have little else that they can agree on, something to talk about without killing one another.  Until recent years it was possible to follow sports without wishing you had a law degree or lawyer on retainer to explain it all to you.  Well, maybe we should dig into this a little more.  Barry Bonds, Lenny Dykstra, Floyd and Lance....there's just so much to mull over.  Here's is a category of law awash in testosterone and greed--it's almost as bad as politics.

Let's talk sports!

Friday, May 6, 2011

Bronx Prosecutor Slammed for Alleged 2d DWI


Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Toiano
 DWI, OVI, DUI, OWI...it's all the same, an alphabet soup meaning the driver was drunk.  Yesterday, the NY Post was blasting an assistant Bronx District Attorney or ADA for continuing to prosecute cases while charges of DWI or whatever they call it in NYC are pending against her.  This is the Post account:

The Bronx assistant DA charged with drunken driving and suspected of using her juice to make an earlier DWI disappear is still prosecuting an amazing 75 cases -- which cops and defense lawyers yesterday called the height of hypocrisy.   'She should be fired outright. Anyone else would have been dismissed from their job a long time ago,' a police source said. 'She's a total disgrace to the Bronx DA's Office.'

Jennifer Troiano, 34, was arrested last August after she was found 'stumbling, falling down . . . on the cellphone walking in lanes of traffic"' after an accident on the Major Deegan Expressway, police said. She is awaiting trial for that arrest and also under investigation for a December 2009 incident, when she was brought to the 44th Precinct on suspicion of DWI only to have the arrest disappear after someone called the officers on her behalf, police sources have said.
But those two black eyes have yet to block her career path with the DA's office, where she works out of the Arson, Auto, Economic Crime Bureau. Her last trial was in March, and "She's in court all the time," a law-enforcement source told The Post.

Troiano's lenient treatment was especially infuriating to police officers, who face automatic 30-day suspensions and other disciplinary action if they are arrested.  'We don't even have to be arrested to be put on administrative leave or modified duty,' a Bronx cop said. 'Anybody can make an allegation against us and they take away your gun and badge so fast you won't believe it.'

The anger also extends to Troiano's own office.

'A lot of people in the DA's office are pissed,' said a defense lawyer who regularly works out of the Bronx courts. 'And we're like, how are you keeping your job?'

Steven Reed, a spokesman for Bronx DA Robert Johnson, said the office does not discipline employees based solely on arrests.

Cops and another defense lawyer found it ironic that a member of the DA's office investigating the massive NYPD ticket-fixing scandal may have had her own ticket fixed.   'If they're investigating cops, I don't understand why they're not investigating her,' said a lawyer defending a case Troiano is prosecuting.

The NYPD is only investigating whether precinct cops helped Troiano after her alleged non-arrest for DWI.

Troiano has declined comment.
_______________________________
A couple of observations:  Miss Troiano is accused or alleged  to have committed these offenses not convicted of anything, yet, although you'd not know that from the tenor of this diatribe. . . , um, story.  Secondly, Miss Troiano must not have made many friends among the cops, press, et al.  Referencing the Bad Lawyer archives should demonstrate that I'm no friend of drunk drivers, especially when they have law licenses, this story is pretty over the top.  It makes me wonder who's dog, Ms. Troiano kicked.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

And Then There's This...Alcoholic Tragedy

At the Oregonian, Aimee Green reports on the tragedy of attorney Shannon Connall.  Here's Aimee Green's account:
"Once prominent defense attorney Shannon Connall pleaded no contest to felony first-degree theft this morning — for an accusation that she stole a client's money.  The plea nearly brings to a close the criminal cases against the 42-year-old, who gave up her Oregon law license last November as the Oregon State Bar investigated allegations that she wrongfully took tens of thousands of dollars of clients’ money.
 
Going into today's hearing, the Multnomah County District Attorney’s Office hadn’t charged her with any crimes for alleged theft from clients.

In the roughly 13 years that she practiced law in Oregon, Connall built a name for herself as she teamed up with her dad, long-time attorney and former Multnomah County District Attorney Des Connall. They took on some of the highest profile criminal cases in the state.

The bar is prosecuting Des Connall professionally for alleged misconduct related to the mishandling of clients’ money. If he loses, he [also]faces a range of punishments — including a public reprimand, suspension or disbarment.

Today, Shannon Connall also pleaded no contest to second-degree criminal mischief, a misdemeanor, for a Feb. 4 incident in which she crashed her father’s Cadillac Escalade into two cars in the upscale Northwest Portland neighborhood of Forest Heights. Investigators say her blood alcohol level was 0.27 percent — more than triple the legal limit — and that she left her dad’s car in the middle of Miller Road as friends unsuccessfully tried to “whisk her away.”

In March, she pleaded no contest to drunken driving and entered a diversion program, which requires her to get alcohol treatment, listen to victims of drunken drivers and follow other court orders. If after one year she has done all that’s required of her, the drunken driving charge will be dismissed — in a deal that’s typically offered to first-time drunken drivers who haven’t injured others.

Today, Judge Michael McShane sentenced Connall to five years of bench probation and 160 hours of community service for the criminal mischief charge. McShane didn't sentence Connall on the theft charge. He plans to see if Connall sticks with treatment and follows other court orders before sentencing her for the theft.
Her law license is still listed as active on the Washington State Bar Association's website, but today's felony plea will likely mean she’ll lose that license, too."
_________________________________________
In the wreckage of this life and career you see a talented professional in the throes of the disease of alcoholism, cunning, baffling and powerful.  Absolutely heartbreaking.  Would we condemn Ms. Connall if she did these terrible acts in the grip of another medically-induced psychosis? 

Sleazy Profiteer Now A Judge!

John "Jack" McConnell, the former Rhode Island plaintiff's (horrors!) mass torts attorney (aka "sleazy profiteer") nominated by President Obama to be a U.S. District Court Judge was confirmed following a cloture vote ending a filibuster.  McConnell's nomination has been the subject of a couple Bad Lawyer posts over the last year.  Congratulations to Judge McConnell.

F&(k^%g Prosecutor

Martha Neil at the ABAJournal.com  links to the story at TimesNews.net story by Jeff Bobo about the Hawkins County (Tennessee) prosecutor (mugshot) who exchanged leniency for sex  from female drug offenders or their mothers.  This is an excerpt from reporter Bobo's story:

"Former Hawkins County prosecutor Doug Godbee has been arrested on a sealed indictment warrant charging him with one count of official misconduct in connection to sexfor-leniency allegations.  The charge is the result of nine complaints made by female drug defendants or mothers of female drug defendants who claim Godbee offered them leniency in court in exchange for sexual favors. In some of those cases sexual contact is alleged, but most involve allegations that Godbee solicited sex in exchange for a favorable outcome in a criminal case.

Godbee, 57, [ . . . ] was named in an April 25 sealed Hawkins ounty grand jury indictment but couldn’t be served with the warrant because he was hospitalized at the time following an apparent overdose of sleeping pills that occurred at his home on April 20.

Special prosecutor Russell Johnson of Kingston told the Times-News Tuesday that although there were nine civil complaints filed against Godbee, and nine alleged victims, the best strategy for a criminal prosecution was to lump all those complaints into one charge of official misconduct. [. . .]
Godbee was arrested Monday evening and released from the Hawkins County Jail on $10,000 bond. A June 3 arraignment date was tentatively set in Hawkins County Criminal Court, although that may change due to the need for a special judge being appointed by the Tennessee Supreme Court to preside over the case. Official misconduct is a Class E felony with a sentence range of one to six years and a fine of up to $3,000. Defendants with no previous record, such as Godbee, are eligible for judicial diversion. In such cases probation would be the sentence, and if the terms of probation were met the defendant’s record would be expunged.

'I’ve already indicated, when his attorney asked me, that I would oppose that,' Johnson said.

Godbee served as an assistant attorney general in Rogersville for more than three decades.  He resigned in 2006 amid allegations he had a sexual relationship with a victim in a case he prosecuted but was reinstated in 2008 after an investigation didn’t result in criminal charges.

He resigned again last September after a female drug defendant and her mother came forward with new allegations."
_____________________________
Wanna guess how many victims are out there over his 3 decade career? 

Jury Deliberating Fate of Man Accused of Killing Two Santa Barbara Attorneys Over Luxury Home Dispute

At midday yesterday, a Santa Barbara jury was in its third day of deliberations in the second murder trial of Corey Lyons for the murder of his brother Daniel Lyons, 55, and Barbara Scharton, 48 both local attorneys.  Daniel Lyons and his longtime girlfriend were pursuing a nasty lawsuit versus Corey Lyons arising out of disputes of the couples luxury home (pic) by Corey Lyons, a builder.

What follows is an excerpt from Jim Guy's report at the Fresno Bee:

"A Santa Barbara County jury began a third full day of deliberation today in the trial of man accused of killing two Fresno attorneys, the district attorney's office said.  Corey Lyons is accused of killing his brother, Daniel Lyons, 55, and Barbara Scharton, 48. The two were shot to death May 4, 2009 in a home they owned in Santa Barbara.

Corey Lyons [was sued] in a lawsuit with his brother [, Daniel Lyons] over the 2,500-square-foot home, which [Corey Lyons] built after tearing down a 1,400-square-foot home not far from a beach. Daniel Lyons sued his brother and Corey Lyons' wife, Mildred, in October 2008, alleging that his brother's company overcharged him, dragged out the construction to milk more money from the project and broke the law by keeping a separate set of books to underreport income to the government, [, and underreported his workers' compensation.] When the project began, Daniel Lyons expected to spend less than $600,000 for the renovation, but the total cost was more than $1.2 million, the suit said.
_____________________________
This story may seem humdrum to you, but to me the story illustrates the pro se lawsuit gone way-wrong, regardless of whether Corey Lyons is innocent or guilty. 

Remember Edgar Steele, Attorney for the Damned? He's Guilty


Steele in better days
Last year Bad Lawyer featured a couple of posts on Edgar Steele, the Aryan, neo-nazi attorney who self-characterized himself as the attorney for "the Damned." 

Steele, a North Idaho attorney was charged by the FBI with plotting to kill among others, his wife and mother-in-law.  At the time of the charges he was free on bond, but the feds found a pipe bomb in the wife's SUV.  Oopsy. 

He's now been convicted on all counts.  The Spokesman-Review account is at the link.

Wanna Buy a Statehouse?

In an Associated Press article at Pennlive.com we learn that many that the going rate is approximately $150,000 and counting.  Here's an excerpt from the story:

"Pennsylvania state lawmakers [took and reported} more than $150,000 in gifts and free food, lodging and transportation last year, according to the latest set of mandatory reports filed with the State Ethics Commission.

[Le]gislators traveled to at least six states and to China, India, Ireland and Switzerland.  For free, they watched NHL games, two were members of the Erie Yacht Club and one took $2,750 worth of ski lift passes.   The state Ethics Act requires public officials to disclose annually any gifts worth at least $250 as well as transportation, lodging or hospitality worth $650 over the course of the year. The reports were due earlier this week.

Rep. Mike Vereb said Tuesday he didn’t realize until much later the cost of a luncheon he and his wife attended during a Pennsylvania Society event in New York.

'I’m not a New York type of guy, and I had no friggin’ clue [ed. nice mild oath] as to the amount,' said Vereb, R-Montgomery. He disclosed the $1,017 cost, a gift of Alpha Natural Resources, a coal company. Alpha’s largesse turned up on at least four other financial statements.

For the Legislature, the total figures are higher than in previous years, in part because an ethics opinion the commission issued several months ago requires disclosure when members get deep discounts on hotel rooms that are not widely available.

Sen. Stewart Greenleaf, R-Montgomery, listed $12,136 worth of construction services [um, remember Ted Stevens] from a retired builder who is helping him construct a new home after his was destroyed in a fire. 'He refused to take any money,' Greenleaf [explained, ed. sure, good one.]

Three senators and a state representative went to Israel, a trip partially underwritten by the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia. Sen. Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland, said she paid all of her cost, while Sen. Daylin Leach, D-Montgomery, said he planned to file an amended report to disclose the trip.

'It was an educational trip,' said Rep. Curt Schroder, R-Chester. 'We meet with members of the Israeli government, press, toured the different hot spot areas, like over near Gaza.'

Rep. Dwight Evans, D-Philadelphia, reported $670 from the Philadelphia Eagles for transportation, hotel accommodations, dinner and tickets to see the team take on the Dallas Cowboys in Texas [ed. another educational trip.]   Evans also received two free $1,000 tickets from the Philadelphia Orchestra for a 'white-tie celebration,' two $1,500 tickets for the Philadelphia National Museum of American Jewish History’s opening gala, and $915 from the Pew Center for the States to attend a 'fiscal leader seminar' in Phoenix. 'The Eagles are a major employer in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania — a lot of jobs, right, all kinds of jobs, a lot of revenue. The orchestra — major attraction in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania,' said Evans, who said he takes a particular interest in state financial issues as a former Appropriations Committee chairman.

Sen. John Pippy, R-Allegheny, spent more than a week in China and India last summer. The cost of more than $19,000 was picked up by the Aspen Institute Rodel Fellowships in Public Leadership of Washington, D.C.   The Legislative Leadership Institute Academy of Foreign Affairs in Green Bay, Wis., spent $12,293 to send Pippy for 10 days to Ireland and Switzerland in December. [ . . . ]
The reports also reveal details about lawmakers’ outside income. At least 30 of them have business relationships with law practices, six with insurance concerns and at least three with the military. More than 20 reported rental or real estate income, while others disclosed proceeds from or ties to accountancy or engineering practices, farming, retail stores, lumber sales, universities, auto repair, auctioneering and a funeral home."
______________________________
This article brilliantly illustrates why constituents are pre-disposed hate law makers.  The weaseling is just so ... what you might expect.

Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Today is the 41st Anniversary of Killing of Students at Kent State

Today is the 41st anniversary of the killing and shooting of students by the State of Ohio's National Guard at Kent State University.  At the link please read the 40th anniversary posts on Bad Lawyer.