Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Anonymous?

The New York Times, published a provocative essay on Alcoholics Anonymous' principle of anonymity.  The point of this "Style and Fashion" story was to challenge the continued viability of the "principle of anonymity."  Here's an excerpt from the piece:

"I’m David C[omitted], and I’m an alcoholic.

In the 15 years since I quit drinking, I’ve neither spoken nor written those words, and now, in doing so, I have more or less violated the first-name-only tenet of Alcoholics Anonymous, the grass-roots organization whose meetings have helped me (and millions of others) quit drinking. As A.A.’s 11th Tradition states, 'We need always maintain personal anonymity at the level of press, radio and films.'

Of course, in the meetings I’ve attended over the years, anonymity has always been a kind of collective fiction. Before and after sessions, I find myself talking to people I know from work: greeting an artist I’ve interviewed or a fashion designer I want to; hashing over logistics with a P.R. guy or a magazine editor. At one of these, a big Sunday meeting in Greenwich Village, I’ve been surprised to see well-known actors and authors up on the dais to share their stories — often, I’ve noticed, when they have something to promote, as if it’s just another a stop on the press tour. Frequently, I find friends introducing me to others in the group by my full name, 'You know David C[omitted], don’t you?'

More and more, anonymity is seeming like an anachronistic vestige of the Great Depression, when A.A. got its start and when alcoholism was seen as not just a weakness but a disgrace.

Over the past few years, so many memoirs about recovery have been released that they constitute a genre unto itself. (Kick Lit?) Moreover, many of them share a format that comes from A.A. itself: most 12-step meetings revolve loosely around what is called a 'qualification' — an informal monologue by one member about his or her battle with the bottle. The last few years have brought us fleshed-out qualifications by Augusten Burroughs ('Dry'), Mary Karr ('Li'”), Nikki Sixx ('The Heroin Diaries'), Eric Clapton ('Clapton: The Autobiography'), Nic Sheff ('Tweak') and James Frey ('A Million Little Pieces,' fabricated, in part, though it was), as well as hundreds of other blurry, cautionary tales of debauchery and redemption. Somewhere, their patron saint — Augustine of Hippo, whose 'Confessions' inaugurated the sinner-cum-saint format in A.D. 398 — is smiling. With precious few exceptions, like Thomas De Quincey’s 'Confessions of an English Opium-Eater' in 1822 and Lillian Roth’s 'I’ll Cry Tomorrow' in 1954, the form barely existed 20 years ago. [ . . .]
'I think it’s extremely healthy that anonymity is fading,' said Clancy M[omitted], a professor of philosophy at the University of Missouri at Kansas City. Mr. M[omitted] broke his anonymity in a 9,000-word essay he wrote in the January issue of Harper’s Magazine detailing his experience getting sober in A.A. and his frustrations with the resistance he met in meetings when trying to talk openly about the psychiatric medications that he, like many recovering addicts, took.

But not everyone is happy about this turn toward openness, chief among them A.A. itself, which last year issued an expanded statement on anonymity that has been read at some meetings, adding language about the importance of discretion on social networking Web sites, hoping to ward off breaches both purposeful and accidental.

Some people have posted pictures taken at A.A. meetings on their Facebook pages, said a spokeswoman [ed. no such person exists] for A.A. who asked not to be identified. In some cases, they may have involuntarily outed other attendees. 'We don’t have the wherewithal to deal with the complaints,' she added. 'It’s literally in the thousands now.'

In the world of recovery — encompassing the greater community of recovering addicts, which overlaps mightily but not officially with A.A. and its alphabet soup of sister groups — anonymity is a concept that, even if it doesn’t feel bit old-fashioned, can be self-defeating.  [. . . ]
'There’s not a day that goes by that some major figure doesn’t announce himself as a substance abuser. There’s a community of people who don’t see it as shameful. These are people that have learned from challenges who have a hunger for life and money to spend, and who want to make up for lost time.'

But even for people who want to be more open, the exact line of where anonymity begins and ends is not clear-cut. Many people assume that to identify themselves as 'sober' or 'in recovery' qualifies as a breach. In fact, only identifying yourself as a member of A.A. or other specific 12-step groups does.

The topic of clarifying these boundaries was brought up yet again at A.A.’s annual General Service Conference, which took place in New York City last week, with debate focused on how the organization’s 'Understanding Anonymity' pamphlet could be best worded to guide those who want to follow the letter or spirit of the principle.

This delicate question was the subject of an essay by Susan C[omitted] in The Fix, titled 'Is It Time to Take the Anonymous Out of A.A.?' Given that she has written books about both her alcoholism and that of her father, the writer John C[omitted], as well as one on the history of A.A., it’s not hard to guess whether she is an A.A. member. But in her essay, she vented her frustrations with trying to observe the practice of anonymity while trying to speak frankly about addiction.

We are in the midst of a public health crisis when it comes to understanding and treating addiction,' Ms. C[omitted] wrote. 'A.A.’s principle of anonymity may only be contributing to general confusion and prejudice.'

Dr. Bob and Bill W.
Her message wasn’t exactly greeted with open arms, inciting a flood of largely critical comments from the site’s readers. (One of the tamer ones: 'Without ANONYMITY, A.A. will not continue to exist and help millions of alcoholics and addicts all over the world!')  [ . . .]

Having written a biography of Bill [W.]— that is, Bill Wilson, one of the founders of A.A. — Ms. C[omitted] is in a position to say what the idea of anonymity was intended to do as few are. First and foremost, anonymity was meant to shield those struggling to become sober from the stigma of being an alcoholic, a stigma far more marked 75 years ago when there was little research on alcoholism as a medical condition over which its sufferers had little control.

These are the most common considerations when weighing the reasons for anonymity. But the second part of the ideal, spelled out in A.A.’s 12th Tradition, makes the case for observing anonymity within A.A. itself — and it’s worth noting that there’s little, if any, dissension on this subject.

Unlike the more practical 11th Tradition, aimed at the outer world, the 12th Tradition takes a crack at our far more problematic inner world. Stating (somewhat obliquely) that 'anonymity is the spiritual foundation of all our traditions, ever reminding us to place principles before personalities,' it’s about cultivating the often overlooked idea of humility, an excellent means for quieting the now-me-more urges that bedevil addictive people more than their peers.

In this light, anonymity is a token, a symbolic gesture, but we are symbolic people. Even shedding your last name can go a surprisingly long way toward shedding the weight of being yourself."
___________________________________
The ABAJournal referred to me as the "anonymous blogger."  I am anonymous.  I believe in anonymity.  The NYT essay on anonymity is foolish, factually inaccurate, and offensive.  

Of course, celebrities and politicians in recovery ignore the rules (traditions)--surprise, surprise it's what got them into drug and alcohol treatment in the first place.  Yes, of course, Bill & Bob and the authors of the AA Big Book and 12 Traditions prophesied that celebs and politicians would self-profess (and self-promote) their membership in AA--it's one of the reasons for the anonymity principle.  All Alcoholics Anonymous needs is a few more spokespersons like the Lohans or any of the other folks who think a little bit of sobriety entitles them to ignore the traditions.   

According to Wikipedia current AA membership hovers around 2 million folks worldwide.  Millions of drunks, and indirectly families, friends and employers have been helped by AA.  It is free.  It works because of its 12 traditions among which Anonymity is primary.  Go ahead, name a more successful program of recovery? 

The debate over anonymity in the comments section of the New York Times article more eloquently lay out all the underlying philosophical and practical reasons for anonymity than I could possibly raise, here.  It works because it's not about me, or Bill W. or any of the celebs, politicians, self-confessional authors--it works because it about "we" and not "me."

Life In Prison for Marijuana

The New Orleans' Times-Picayune reports on the Slidell man sentenced to life in prison following his fourth conviction for marijuana. 

"Cornell Hood II got off with probation after three marijuana convictions in New Orleans.
He didn't fare too well after moving to St. Tammany Parish, however. A single such conviction on the north shore landed the 35-year-old in prison for the rest of his life.  State Judge Raymond S. Childress punished Hood under Louisiana's repeat-offender law in his courtroom in Covington on Thursday. A jury on Feb. 15 found the defendant guilty of attempting to possess and distribute marijuana at his Slidell home, court records show.

Hood moved from eastern New Orleans to the Slidell area after he admitted to separate charges of distribution of marijuana and possession with intent to distribute marijuana on Dec. 18, 2009, in Orleans Parish Criminal District Court. He received a suspended five-year prison sentence and five years' of probation for each -- which was precisely the same penalty he got in that court after pleading guilty to possessing and intending to distribute marijuana on Feb. 22, 2005.

When Hood switched homes, he also requested a new probation officer based in St. Tammany. Authorities granted the wish, and the officer, Dustin Munlin, drove to Hood's place for a routine visit on Sept. 27, 2010.

Munlin found nearly two pounds of pot throughout the house, according to court records. He alerted Sheriff's Office deputies. They arrested Hood, who apparently shared the King's Point house with his mother and young son.  Prosecutors later charged him with one count of possession with intent to distribute marijuana.

At Hood's one-day trial, the evidence presented by the prosecution included a digital scale and about a dozen bags that had contained marijuana before being seized from the house, testimony showed. Deputies also found $1,600 in cash and a student-loan application with Hood's name on it inside of a night stand.

Jurors deliberated for less than two hours and convicted Hood of a reduced charge, which usually carries no more than 15 years' imprisonment. Assistant District Attorney Nick Noriea Jr. then used Hood's past convictions on Thursday to argue that he was a career criminal worthy of a severe punishment.

Drug offenders in the state are subject to life imprisonment after being convicted three or more times of a crime that carries a sentence exceeding 10 years."
____________________________
I'm sure someone out there knows the answer to this, I don't--during Prohibition could multiple convictions of running a speakeasy get you life in prison? 

Boys With Toys: Now a New and Improved TASER, The ShotGun, Say What . . .?

You build it and the cops will buy it.  Better yet, they'll unleash the technology on you!  Tampa Bay's WTSP Channel 10 news has this report  (at the link check the video) on the new shotgun-based taser technology.  Grrrrreeeaat!

"There's a new TASER in town that looks like something out of a James Bond movie. It packs a powerful punch and can stop the bad guys in their tracks longer than a stun gun can.   Polk County Sheriff's Office SWAT team members say the taser has already saved lives [ed. sure, they do!].

They point to a terrifying scene from inside an Auburndale home last Christmas when a convicted sex offender, 27-year-old Jason Robinson, was accused of brutally attacking his brother and threatening to kill the entire family.  In victim's statements to police Jason's brother Adam Lee Robinson explained to detectives after the alleged incident, 'He starts stomping on my ribs and he actually jumps up and stomps on my testicle.'  Jason is accused of barricading himself inside the house and that's when the Polk County SWAT team members moved in. Paul Butler is a member of the SWAT team and says, 'So we pushed the front door of the house open with that to try to get his attention. I utilized a shotgun that we have with the TASER XREP round."' [ed. OK how did this TASER change anything?]

Polk County Sheriff's Office is one of only about two dozen law enforcement agencies in Florida using the powerful new TASER Extended Range Electronic Projectile (XREP).  It's fired from a 12 gauge shotgun from up to a 100 feet away. It's 14 grams, has wing like fins that spread open as it takes flight. It has painful probes and pins that stick into your body. It packs all the powerful punch and stopping power of a stun gun and is enclosed in a 12 gauge shotgun shell and when it hits you it locks up your muscles.

John Angleton is the taser coordinator for the sheriff's office and says, 'It's the most excruciating pain imaginable. It locks everything up. For one you cannot move. You can breathe because you're screaming at the top of your lungs.' [ed.  Can't you just hear the glee?  Imagine how much fun they'll have firing this Baby!]

The TASER XREP keeps a suspect down for 20 seconds [ed. if not foreever] instead of 5 seconds which is how long the traditional taser keeps a suspect down. The traditional taser also has to be fired from a closer range within 21 feet.  While TASER XREP rounds cost a hundred dollars each SWAT team members say they're worth the price because they save lives.  [ed. You betcha!]

They say the rounds saved Jason Robinson's life. Deputy Butler says, 'When he fell - he fell within inches of a butcher knife that was on the floor but thankfully he fell on top the XREP round. That round immobilized him and allowed us to get in and secure him.' Butler adds, 'So that 20 seconds gives us plenty of time to get into the home or get into wherever we're at or close the distance between us and the suspect and take them into custody before they're able to do something to harm themselves or harm us.'

The TASER XREP is only available to law enforcement agencies and not the general public. While the cartridges are expensive Polk County Sheriff's Office only allows their SWAT team to use them."

Tuesday, May 10, 2011

George Steinbrenner, Snitch

Before there was the Donald, there was the Boss--George Steinbrenner, famous blowhard and ex-felon, or as his former Yankee Manager Billy Martin called him, "convicted liar."

Turns out that a FOIA request turned up documents showing that The Boss was a repeat FBI informant, a snitch.  Steinbrenner's reward, a presidential pardon.

Plagiarizing the Plagiarist: On Quoting Bob Dylan in Legal Opinions

Robert Allen Zimmerman, the kid from Hibbing, Minnesota,  is without a doubt a giant among 20th century songwriters.  He is on one level a supreme genius and on the other hand one of the thieves of time or in other words: plagiarist.  With his emergence in 1961 Bob Dylan was aping Woody Guthrie and other leading folk singers and borrowing from Dylan Thomas or as he said, "This is the land of the free."  Legendary songwriter Joni Mitchell trashed Dylan as a plagiarist in this April, 2010 La Times interview reviving arguments about Dylan, plagiarism, and art.  I realize, of course, that a blogger talking about plagiarism is pretty ironic.  Hell, maybe that's what Dylan was all along, . . . a blogger before his time.

For a law blawger it's amusing to take note that a study by law professor Alex Long at the University of Texas that combed legal opinions quoting music lyrics.  The research confirms that Judges (and presumably clever law clerks) "in apparent efforts to add rhetorical flourish to their rulings, judges [quote Dylan's lyrics]" most frequently.  Or put another way, to be hip and cool.

Once again, hat tip to the ABAJournal website.

"[Sir, You are] Gayer than a Sweet Smelling Jock Strap"

The tireless blawgers (Debra Cassens Weiss and Marhta Neil) at the ABAJournal website have unearthed a couple of remarkable news items which illustrate the propensity of Judges to unhinge a bit in their pronouncements from the bench.  The following video speaks for itself:


Georgia Judge: OK, You Can Wear that Weird Muslim Hat in my Courtroom

A Georgia State Court judge has done his own research, yep...sure enough the mooslim man was not lying when he claimed to be wearing that Cooofee hat for religious reasons.  Judge James T. Chafin reversed his earlier order barring the wearing of a Kufi (pic, Usher in his Kufi) in his courtroom, this is Alexis Stevens' story at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution: 

"A [state] judge has reversed his own decision and will allow a Muslim man to wear his head covering in the courtroom

'The Court finds through its own research that there is a basis in the Quran for both men and women to cover their heads as a religious observance,'  Judge James T. Chafin wrote in an order obtained by the AJC. 'Accordingly, the Court will permit the defendant to wear his hat in the courtroom as a valid religious observance.'

Chafin had blocked Troy “Tariq” Montgomery [ . . .] from entering the courtroom three separate times to defend a speeding charge, attorney Mawuli Mel Davis told the AJC. Montgomery, 46, wears a kufi, a tight-fitting cap, as a symbol of humility at all times, Davis said.  But Chafin previously requested to see proof, such as in a religious doctrine, that Montgomery must wear the kufi, which violated Montgomery's rights, Davis said.

A policy enacted in 2009 already allows religious head coverings to be worn in courtrooms.
In December 2008, Lisa Valentine was arrested in Douglas County for refusing to remove her headdress, called a hijab. The ACLU filed a lawsuit in Valentine's behalf, and in July 2009, the Georgia Judicial Council adopted a policy clarifying that religious head coverings can be worn in Georgia courthouses.

'I was surprised when I got the news and hopeful that no other Muslims will have to face these objections of wearing their Islamic attire in court,' Montgomery said in a statement issued through his attorney. 'I also want to make it clear that I do not just wear a ‘hat' as the judge referred to in his order, but a kufi, which is a religious head covering worn for the purpose of identifying my religious affiliation.'"
_________________________________________
I saw a lot of Kufis, Yarmulkes, and other sorts of religious head wear while at Morgantown.  Of course, OurTown is a large metropolitan area and truth be told I know what a Kufi is and I know something about the significance of religious head wear.  The really unusual look for me was the Rastafarian headwear, or Rasta caps, (pic)  Among the Jamaicans at Morgantown there were guys with dreads so long that when stuffed in a knit cap the wearer resembled a Rasta-Marge Simpson.

Annals of Dumb Ass Law Enforcement

The following item by reporeter Joel Burgess from the Asheville Citizen-Times speaks for itself:

Antonio Hernandez Carranza took a wrong turn, and it turned out to be one of the biggest mistakes he's ever made.  The Carson, Calif., man had driven more than 2,000 miles — three days straight — to see his sister in Johnson City, Tenn.  But instead of reaching the home of his sister, whom he hadn't seen in nearly a decade, the 45-year-old carpet cleaner found himself in the Buncombe County jail under a $300,000 bond on charges of driving while intoxicated, failing to heed police lights and sirens and possession of 91 pounds of cocaine.  He was released four days later after sheriff's deputies realized Hernandez, who said he doesn't drink at all, wasn't intoxicated and that what was in the back of his truck was exactly what he had said — $400 worth of cheese, shrimp and tortilla and tamale dough meant as a gift to his sister.

Now struggling to reclaim his truck and dog that were taken away, Hernandez said he wants only to see his family and possibly get some compensation for his time and expenses.

While in jail, he called his wife, Bernice, to tell her that he could be facing 40 years in prison and may never see her or their two boys again.  'She and the kids were crying. She was inconsolable,' Hernandez said through an interpreter.

Local residents affiliated with Latino advocacy groups say Hernandez, a legal resident who understands a fair amount of English but doesn't speak it well, was targeted because of his ethnicity.  Deputies said Hernandez appeared drunk and they acted quickly to get narcotics test results after he was jailed.

Buncombe County Sheriff's Office Lt. Randy Smart acknowledged that four days in jail under an extremely high bond seemed a stiff penalty for failing to heed police lights and sirens, of which Hernandez was found guilty.

'It's one of those things when you go back and look at it, it does seem a little harsh,' the Sheriff's Office spokesman said.

Hernandez, who came to the United States in1985 to harvest grapes and strawberries, was not a legal resident until 1989 when he received amnesty under a federal program signed into law by President Ronald Reagan.  Through that status, he was able to gain employment, such as at the carpet cleaning company, where he now works and had accrued vacation.

While driving to his sister's home, he said he encountered police in Arizona and Texas who also questioned him about what he was carrying and appeared to suspect drugs.

'The police in Texas used dogs to check,' he said.

Each time, he said he was sent on his way. He's not sure how he ended up in Asheville, but believes he stayed on Interstate 40 when he should have turned onto Interstate 81 after Knoxville.  He was tired, but he said he kept driving because he was excited to see his sister.  In Asheville, he pulled over after he thought he saw steam coming from his truck. A deputy's car approached and an officer told him he couldn't stop there because he was blocking traffic, Hernandez said.

He started driving away and put his flashers on. The law enforcement car followed him with its lights on. Hernandez said he thought the car was shepherding him in the direction the officer wanted him to go. But ahead there were other law enforcement cars blocking his way.

Investigators' incident reports say stop sticks were used, but Hernandez said he doesn't remember seeing them or noticing his tires being deflated until seeing his truck days later in the impound lot.

Officers pulled him from the car, put a knee in his back and pinned his arm behind him, leaving scrapes and bruises.

He was tested several times for alcohol but it came back negative. It was after he was jailed that he learned of the cocaine charges. He said he tried to explain about the dough and how some was already made up for sweet pineapple tamales, but no one seemed to listen. 'Later I was speechless. I didn't eat or sleep while I was in jail. I was thinking about how this could have happened to me,' he said.

His court date was set for May 19. But Wednesday, he was brought out of the jail and to the courtroom where there was a public defender, a prosecutor and a judge.  He said he was told he was being found guilty of the one misdemeanor charge and would get credit for his time served in jail. He doesn't remember being asked to enter a plea.  On Thursday, Fay Burner, who defended Hernandez, said she couldn't talk about the case without his permission.

It's not clear why deputies originally thought the food was cocaine. It could have been that initial checks showed the dough and other items were narcotics, Smart said.  'We do field tests for presumptive testing,' the lieutenant said. Officers later appeared to push to get full lab tests done quickly, he said.

District Attorney Ron Moore said he wasn't sure of the details of the case and hadn't seen a written report. Others said Hernandez was treated poorly because he is a Latino of Indian origin with limited English.

'If he were white it would have been different,' said Gustavo Silva, a local Latino rights advocate. Silva, a U.S. citizen originally from Uruguay, went to help Hernandez after getting a call from someone in the courthouse about his plight.

Neither he nor Hernandez is sure he'll ever be paid for his trouble, including the food which is gone or the fees for retrieving his truck.  'I asked in court, ‘Who's going to pay me for what I lost?' They said, ‘I don't know. It's not my problem,' Hernandez said."
____________________________
Yeah, further proof if you needed any, why anit-immigration law enforcement makes so little sense.  It leads to abuses like these.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Toilet Talk

At any given moment there are something like 2.5 million persons incarcerated in the United States and 9.25 million worldwide.  Every inmate, no matter how much he or she resists, eventually eats jail food thereby bringing them to that magic moment that those of us not in jail imagine must be incredibly uncomfortable--taking a shit.  Guess what?  You are right.

Taking a dump in jail is just one of those terrible indignities of being in jail, well ... along with everything else.

Obviously, the worse is being in a two or three man cell using the stainless steel jail toilet.  In my case I spent a month + 8 days in the hole using this wonderful device, see pic.  My experience is that you and your cellee(s) work it out amongst one another to minimize embarrassment.  When I was in the HOLE my cellee, Jason and I would announce the need to "make a deposit" and the other guy would roll over in the bunk and face the wall.  Nice.  When I was at CCA and could wander the cell block, you timed your use for when your cellee was out in the common area and vice versa.  Hang and towel or use some other signal you had relative privacy.  Not really, but all in all tolerable.

These stainless steel toilet/sinks are designed for security.  Allegedly it's impossible to kill yourself or injure a cellee with this toilet.  No toilet seat to beat one another to death with.  One of the odd things about the toilet system design you can talk "through the toilet" with other inmates.  Weird, huh?  Why?  Well, I'm not sure I really understand this, but according to a couple of guys who spent considerable time in large metropolitan jails mail and female inmates are sometimes housed on different levels of tiered facilities.  The jail cell toilets are used to "flirt" and odd little relationships blossom via inmate toilets.  An inmate told me that he knew of situations where these marginal relationships formed and fights would break out when their so-called girlfriends were overheard flirting with another inmate.  I actually, thought these guys were pulling my leg, but check the link.


Birdeye view of FCI, Morgantown
 Once I got to Morgantown, the toilets became what you would expect to find in your local college dormitory, doors and all.  Nonetheless prison etiquette mandates that the user flush the toilet CONSTANTLY.  These so-called courtesy flushes executed on commercial toilets by inmates day and night are part of the cacophony of jail. 

Let's face it, there is nothing--absolutely nothing sexy about jail.  And yet certain rules, including the absurd requirement that after a shower you dress IN THE SHOWER. As I thought about this more it occurred to me that this was part of the homophobia of jail.  By doing this individuals announced "I'm not gay, and you aren't gay."  But there was a very definite and apparently unmolested gay population including some pretty flamboyant guys.  In the multi-purpose room at the rec center there was a "gay table."  One evening, Big Gay Al was standing at a Chow Hall table shouting to a friend in line, "Tameeekaaaa, oh Tameeekaaa," while his pals laughed appreciatively.  

Don't do what I did.  Experience all these marvels vicariously. 

Carolina Panther's Linebacker Goes On Trial for Punching-out Strip Club Patron

Here's a garden variety, ho-hum sports-related story:  Carolina Panther's Linebacker Jon Beason (pic) goes to trial this week in a civil suit arising out of his assault and battery upon a fellow Strip Club patron in November 2009. 

You could easily interchange the names, pics and towns of dozens of young athletes for  Jon Beason's for the story at the Charlotte Observer, today.  In some instances there are criminal charges--there were criminal allegations against Beason, not pursued.  Sometimes guns are involved, sometimes impaired driving; drugs; baby moms. 

At local news websites these errant athlete stories are more common than child porn prosecutions.  I imagine there are several factors that make this so:  athletes are targets; athletes are youngsters; athletes tend to habituate bars, clubs, and parties;  athletes are narcissistic individuals who buy into the message:  you are special, the rules do not apply to you.  This latter message kicks in around the time a talented kid joins Pop Warner football programs continuing all through their "education," and professional career, if any.