Wednesday, May 18, 2011
Annals of Really Stupid Criminals: DNA Innocence, Well Maybe Not
A report by Peter Busch at KPHO CBS 5 News is worth considering. Timothy Boles, a convicted rapist demanded DNA testing and you guessed it--he was guilty. But more than guilty, the DNA evidence linked him to an unsolved 1991 rape of a twelve year old. Good one, Tim. Enjoy your life sentence.
Attorneys: Kidnapper/Rapist Didn't Cause No Harm!
![]() |
| Brian David Mitchell (right) |
Always leading the pack of these nauseating news items are the stories of crimes against children. With exceptions those stories do not find their way onto this blawg for a variety of reasons not the least of which is the lack of a Bad Lawyer-angle. But the story and headline at the Salt Lake Tribune detailing the claims of defense lawyers for Brian David Mitchell, Elizabeth Smart's kidnapper and rapist, have me smoking. According to Melinda Roberts story Mitchell's lawyers claim that Mitchell should receive a lesser prison sentence because he didn't cause Elizabeth Smart "Psychological Injur[ies.]" The following is an excerpt from Ms. Roberts' report:
"Elizabeth Smart has repeatedly claimed her abusers didn’t destroy her plans for a happy future — a stance that may now be used by defense attorneys seeking to lessen the pending prison sentence for Brian David Mitchell. In court documents filed this month, defense attorneys argue that Mitchell did not cause 'extreme psychological injury' to Smart when he kidnapped the then-14-year-old girl from her bedroom at knifepoint [ . . . ], to make her [his] plural wife.
As proof, the defense points to Smart’s public comments of how she survived her horrific 9-month ordeal at the hands of Mitchell and his wife, Wanda Eileen Barzee, who threatened to kill her and her family if she didn’t comply with their wishes.
'Counsel does not agree that Extreme Psychological Injury [to the victim] is applicable in this case, since its application is directly contradicted by the testimony of Ms. Smart and argument by the government, who vigorously argued that Ms. Smart is a ‘survivor’ who has not been psychologically injured more than other victims of the offenses at issue,' wrote defense attorneys Robert Steele and Parker Douglas.
The defense comments are intended as objections to a pre-sentence report filed by a federal probation officer. The report will be considered by U.S. District Judge Dale Kimball at a May 25 sentencing hearing for the 57-year-old Mitchell, who faces up to life in prison. [. . . ]
Smart testified at a five-week trial in December that Mitchell marched her at knifepoint to a mountain campsite above her Salt Lake City home, where he consummated their "marriage," and then continued to rape her almost daily. The girl, who for a time was tethered to a tree, was forced to watch Mitchell and Barzee engage in sexual activity as a way to "educate" her. The couple also forced her to smoke marijuana and cigarettes and drink alcohol. Later, the trio traveled to California. When they returned to Utah in March 2003, the homeless street preacher and his wife were arrested, and Smart was rescued.
Smart testified that as a survival strategy, she gave up any thought of escape.
'No matter what it took, I would live,' Smart testified at trial. 'I would survive and do everything he told me to do to keep my life and my family’s life intact.' But Smart acknowledged that she initially felt that the rape made her feel dirty and that she wanted to die — ammunition that prosecutors may use to show Mitchell’s actions did cause psychological trauma."
___________________________________
These sort of patently absurd and villainous assertions by counsel provide a basis for the caricature of criminal defense attorneys. While I accept the principle that unpopular defendants deserve defense, every reasonable defense--I don't get this sort of outrageous mischaracterization of a rape victim's testimony. I don't believe this sort of disingenuous argument does anything advantageous for the defendant and on the contrary spin like this risks provoking a sentencing judge. Or is that the point?
Actually there are certain classes of injuries that are so obvious that laypersons can readily understand the injury--kidnapping and regularly raping a 14 year old, is one of those. Mitchell took Elizabeth Smart's adolescence, and her innocence and only his lawyers don't seem to understand that. You know, I'm not angry that Mitchell's lawyers make these arguments in their objections to the Pre-Sentence Investigation, I'm angry that they leaked these arguments to the press, if they did.
Here Comes the Judge!--Judge Arditti Returns to Bench Following Acquittal
Judge Regina Arditi (pic) returned to her West Texas courtroom following her acquittal on bribery and corruption charges. This is the Associated Press account from the Houston Chronicle website:
"A suspended judge expects to be back on the state district court bench in El Paso a day after her acquittal [on] corruption charges. Regina Arditti returns to her judicial duties Thursday after El Paso County jurors acquitted her Wednesday of two bribery counts, two counts of [abuse] of official capacity and one of prohibition applicable to trading.
Prosecutors had accused the judge of agreeing to hire state District Judge Manuel Barraza's sister as court coordinator in return for Barraza agreeing to hire Arditti's son as a bailiff. Barraza also was charged in the case, but those charges were dropped when he was sentenced to five years in prison in July in a federal bribery case. [Judge Barraza] was reindicted [on state charges] and is scheduled for trial May 23[rd.]_____________________________
Bet this judge has a new outlook! A wee bit more empathy for the criminally-accused, perhaps?
"A suspended judge expects to be back on the state district court bench in El Paso a day after her acquittal [on] corruption charges. Regina Arditti returns to her judicial duties Thursday after El Paso County jurors acquitted her Wednesday of two bribery counts, two counts of [abuse] of official capacity and one of prohibition applicable to trading.
Prosecutors had accused the judge of agreeing to hire state District Judge Manuel Barraza's sister as court coordinator in return for Barraza agreeing to hire Arditti's son as a bailiff. Barraza also was charged in the case, but those charges were dropped when he was sentenced to five years in prison in July in a federal bribery case. [Judge Barraza] was reindicted [on state charges] and is scheduled for trial May 23[rd.]_____________________________
Bet this judge has a new outlook! A wee bit more empathy for the criminally-accused, perhaps?
Fatal Car Crashes Cost $41 Billion a Year!
According to a study from the CDC (Center for Disease Control) fatal car accidents cost $41 billion dollars. Statistics for 2005 (31,000 fatalities) data demonstrate the financial impact in the CDC study. Over half of all economic impact is traceable to 10 states. California ($4.16 billion), Texas ($3.50 billion), Florida ($3.16 billion), Georgia ($1.55 billion), Pennsylvania ($1.52 billion), North Carolina ($1.50 billion), New York ($1.33 billion), Illinois ($1.32 billion), Ohio ($1.23 billion), and Tennessee ($1.15 billion). The CDC makes the following recommendations:
"To prevent crash-related deaths and reduce medical and work loss costs, CDC's Injury Center recommends that states consider the following strategies:
•Primary seat belt laws, which allow motorists to be stopped and cited for not wearing seat belts. Seat belts reduce the risk of death to those riding in the front seat by about half.
•Strong child passenger safety policies, which require children to be placed in age- and size-appropriate child safety and booster seats while riding in vehicles.
•Comprehensive graduated driver licensing (GDL) systems, which are proven to reduce teen crashes. GDL systems help new drivers gain experience under lower-risk conditions by granting driving privileges in stages. The most comprehensive GDL systems have been associated with up to 40 percent decreases in crashes among 16-year-old drivers.
•Universal motorcycle helmet laws, which require riders of all ages to wear helmets. Helmet use can reduce the risk of death in a motorcycle crash by more than one-third and reduce the risk of brain injury by 69 percent.
'These preventable costs are a reflection of the terrible suffering of American families whose loved ones are killed or injured on the roads,' said Norman Mineta, chairman of Make Roads Safe North America and the longest serving Secretary of Transportation in U.S. history. 'Today, on the launch of the first-ever Decade of Action for Road Safety, occurring in 30 cities across our nation and 50 countries worldwide, it is time for all of us to take action to save lives at home and around the globe.'"
"To prevent crash-related deaths and reduce medical and work loss costs, CDC's Injury Center recommends that states consider the following strategies:
•Primary seat belt laws, which allow motorists to be stopped and cited for not wearing seat belts. Seat belts reduce the risk of death to those riding in the front seat by about half.
•Strong child passenger safety policies, which require children to be placed in age- and size-appropriate child safety and booster seats while riding in vehicles.
•Comprehensive graduated driver licensing (GDL) systems, which are proven to reduce teen crashes. GDL systems help new drivers gain experience under lower-risk conditions by granting driving privileges in stages. The most comprehensive GDL systems have been associated with up to 40 percent decreases in crashes among 16-year-old drivers.
•Universal motorcycle helmet laws, which require riders of all ages to wear helmets. Helmet use can reduce the risk of death in a motorcycle crash by more than one-third and reduce the risk of brain injury by 69 percent.
'These preventable costs are a reflection of the terrible suffering of American families whose loved ones are killed or injured on the roads,' said Norman Mineta, chairman of Make Roads Safe North America and the longest serving Secretary of Transportation in U.S. history. 'Today, on the launch of the first-ever Decade of Action for Road Safety, occurring in 30 cities across our nation and 50 countries worldwide, it is time for all of us to take action to save lives at home and around the globe.'"
Tuesday, May 17, 2011
Bad Idea! Harassing Calls to the Supreme Court Because You Disagree with a Decision
In a remarkable news item the Associated Press it is reported that the Indiana Supreme Court is receiving harassing phone calls and emails over a decision it issued last week. In a 3-2 decision of the Indiana Supreme Court, the court upheld the arrest of Richard L. Barnes who was charged with misdemeanor disorderly conduct for barring the door to his residence when the police made a warrantless entrance.
Making harassing phone calls and sending harassing emails to a court is always a bad idea.
Making harassing phone calls and sending harassing emails to a court is always a bad idea.
Florida DUI Attorney An Unnatural Disaster
Destin, Florida (the Panhandle) DUI "Barrister" R. Scott Whitehead who is completing a 21 month sentence for multiple DUIs involving collisions, is probably not going anywhere fast. This is and excerpt from reporter Tom McLaughlin's piece for the Panama City News Herald:
"Destin attorney R. Scott Whitehead, who is serving a 21-month sentence for several alcohol-related violations, was charged Monday with racketeering. [ed. He is scheduled to be released May 26.]
[ . . . ]A news release sent out by the State Attorney’s Office said Whitehead was charged with 'aggravated white collar crime and racketeering' — both first-degree felonies. It said that from 2005 through 2010, Whitehead 'illegally obtained hundreds of thousands of dollars from dozens of his former clients.'
It said Whitehead lied to clients, billed them for services he didn’t render and made unauthorized charges on their credit cards. An addendum of probable cause for the arrest indicates investigators found at least 27 people who claimed to be victims of Whitehead’s crimes.
One woman claimed she lost custody of her child due to Whitehead’s lack of attention to her case. Kye Lin, owner of The Shanghai restaurant in Niceville, claims to have lost more than $50,000.
Summer Suggs told authorities she hired Whitehead to assist her in a child custody case. The probable cause affidavit states she paid the attorney $8,000 and he 'promised that custody would be reversed.' Suggs told investigators that Whitehead failed to return phone calls and 'appeared high, sweating and belligerent' at court appearances and meetings.
[In the restaurant case, Whitehead got ahold of the client's credit card information and ] as her case progressed, Ms. Lin noticed numerous credit card charges were transacted on from her credit card accounts by Mr. Whitehead … the total unauthorized charges exceed $50,000,' the report said. Lin said the charges on her card were unauthorized and, when she asked Whitehead for reimbursement, he told her 'the insurance company would reimburse her.' [ . . . ] The state attorney trying the case in question vouched [ed. you've got to be kidding!] for Whitehead’s character, the affidavit stated. [ . . . ]
Whitehead has been in jail since October 2010, when County Judge T. Patterson Maney added an additional nine months to a 12-month sentence because probation officers reported he’d failed to submit to an alcohol test. [. . . ]
It started when he was arrested twice in an eight-day period in 2009 for leaving the scene of an accident, speeding, driving with a suspended license and DUI.
He violated his probation on those charges when he was arrested for criminal mischief in August 2009. He was arrested again in May 2010 for violating his probation. He entered the home of man who didn't know him and asked about a woman named “Becky” or “Barbara.”
A sheriff's deputy reported at the time of the last arrest that Whitehead appeared intoxicated and urinated on himself [ed. nice detail.] If convicted of the racketeering and aggravated white collar crime charges, Whitehead faces up to 60 years in prison, the State Attorney’s Office news release states."
_________________________________
The Alcoholic Anonymous "Big Book" says that alcoholism, the disease, operates like a tornado in our lives and the lives of those we touch, our friends and family. I don't know if Whitehead is an alcoholic, but he sure was a tornado in the lives of his clients.
"Destin attorney R. Scott Whitehead, who is serving a 21-month sentence for several alcohol-related violations, was charged Monday with racketeering. [ed. He is scheduled to be released May 26.]
[ . . . ]A news release sent out by the State Attorney’s Office said Whitehead was charged with 'aggravated white collar crime and racketeering' — both first-degree felonies. It said that from 2005 through 2010, Whitehead 'illegally obtained hundreds of thousands of dollars from dozens of his former clients.'
It said Whitehead lied to clients, billed them for services he didn’t render and made unauthorized charges on their credit cards. An addendum of probable cause for the arrest indicates investigators found at least 27 people who claimed to be victims of Whitehead’s crimes.
One woman claimed she lost custody of her child due to Whitehead’s lack of attention to her case. Kye Lin, owner of The Shanghai restaurant in Niceville, claims to have lost more than $50,000.
Summer Suggs told authorities she hired Whitehead to assist her in a child custody case. The probable cause affidavit states she paid the attorney $8,000 and he 'promised that custody would be reversed.' Suggs told investigators that Whitehead failed to return phone calls and 'appeared high, sweating and belligerent' at court appearances and meetings.
[In the restaurant case, Whitehead got ahold of the client's credit card information and ] as her case progressed, Ms. Lin noticed numerous credit card charges were transacted on from her credit card accounts by Mr. Whitehead … the total unauthorized charges exceed $50,000,' the report said. Lin said the charges on her card were unauthorized and, when she asked Whitehead for reimbursement, he told her 'the insurance company would reimburse her.' [ . . . ] The state attorney trying the case in question vouched [ed. you've got to be kidding!] for Whitehead’s character, the affidavit stated. [ . . . ]
Whitehead has been in jail since October 2010, when County Judge T. Patterson Maney added an additional nine months to a 12-month sentence because probation officers reported he’d failed to submit to an alcohol test. [. . . ]
It started when he was arrested twice in an eight-day period in 2009 for leaving the scene of an accident, speeding, driving with a suspended license and DUI.
He violated his probation on those charges when he was arrested for criminal mischief in August 2009. He was arrested again in May 2010 for violating his probation. He entered the home of man who didn't know him and asked about a woman named “Becky” or “Barbara.”
A sheriff's deputy reported at the time of the last arrest that Whitehead appeared intoxicated and urinated on himself [ed. nice detail.] If convicted of the racketeering and aggravated white collar crime charges, Whitehead faces up to 60 years in prison, the State Attorney’s Office news release states."
_________________________________
The Alcoholic Anonymous "Big Book" says that alcoholism, the disease, operates like a tornado in our lives and the lives of those we touch, our friends and family. I don't know if Whitehead is an alcoholic, but he sure was a tornado in the lives of his clients.
The Arizona Republic's Robert Robb on What Arpaio Cost the Taxpayers
Yesterday, I brought you the story of Andrew Thomas' shameless shakedown of the Maricopa taxpayers for funds to pay for his defense against ethics charges; today I bring you a link to the Arizona Republic's outraged columnist Robert Robb on Sheriff Joe Arpaio's role in what Robb terms, the Maricopa County "cesspool." Prompting Robb's May 11th column was the release of the independent investigation conducted by the Pinal County Sheriff's office.
AZCentral.com's links to the Pinal County investigation. Mind-blowing. But hey, it's worth it to have America's Toughest Sheriff working for you, right?
AZCentral.com's links to the Pinal County investigation. Mind-blowing. But hey, it's worth it to have America's Toughest Sheriff working for you, right?
Lexington, Ky. Human Rights Lawyer Under Arrest for "fisticuffs" following Vehicular Assault on Girlfriend
In what I am sure will turn out to be an alcohol or drug-fueled domestic violence incident, attorney J. Scott Benton is under arrest for attacking his girlfriend with an automobile and resulting "fisticuffs." Benton, an interim counsel for the Lexington-Fayette Urban County Human Rights Commission is free on bond after being charged with wanton endangerment following a fight that left his girlfriend lying unconscious in the street according to a report at the Lousiville Courier-Journal.
"J. Scott Benton, who works at the Benton Law Offices, has been charged with wanton endangerment after the fisticuffs at about 2 a.m. . . Saturday.
Lexington police say Benton and a woman identifying herself as his girlfriend began arguing near downtownPolice said Benton drove his car at the woman just missing her. Officers said he then got out of his car with a gun and hit the woman, knocking her to the ground and causing unconsciousness.
Police said Benton got into his car and drove away, but eventually returned and was pointed out by several witnesses."
_______________________________
In the blink of an eye, there goes your reputation and career, young lawyer.
"J. Scott Benton, who works at the Benton Law Offices, has been charged with wanton endangerment after the fisticuffs at about 2 a.m. . . Saturday.
Lexington police say Benton and a woman identifying herself as his girlfriend began arguing near downtownPolice said Benton drove his car at the woman just missing her. Officers said he then got out of his car with a gun and hit the woman, knocking her to the ground and causing unconsciousness.
Police said Benton got into his car and drove away, but eventually returned and was pointed out by several witnesses."
_______________________________
In the blink of an eye, there goes your reputation and career, young lawyer.
Monday, May 16, 2011
NY Tax Dodging State Senator Gets 2 years at Club Fed
The New York Daily News is reporting that the former State Senator convicted on multiple counts of tax evasion who offered his services as a diplomat in lieu of jail, was sentenced to 2 years at the nearby Club Fed instead. The story:
"[L]ongtime state legislator who admitted evading taxes and trying to influence a grand jury was sentenced Friday to nearly two years in prison. Former state Sen. Vincent Leibell pleaded guilty in December, resigning after 28 years in the state Legislature. Federal guidelines suggest a sentence of 18 to 24 months, and prosecutors had asked for the upper limit. The judge decided on 21 months.
Leibell had suggested that instead of prison, he be assigned to an American "nation-building team" in the Middle East. The Department of Justice called that request absurd, and the judge didn't mention it at sentencing.
Leibell, a Republican, had been elected Putnam County executive a month before his guilty plea. He gave up that post as well as the last month of his Senate term.
He admitted he filed false tax returns for 2003 through 2006. Leibell spent 12 years in the Assembly before his 16 years in the Senate. The felony convictions don't affect his public pension, estimated at about $70,000 a year."
"[L]ongtime state legislator who admitted evading taxes and trying to influence a grand jury was sentenced Friday to nearly two years in prison. Former state Sen. Vincent Leibell pleaded guilty in December, resigning after 28 years in the state Legislature. Federal guidelines suggest a sentence of 18 to 24 months, and prosecutors had asked for the upper limit. The judge decided on 21 months.
Leibell had suggested that instead of prison, he be assigned to an American "nation-building team" in the Middle East. The Department of Justice called that request absurd, and the judge didn't mention it at sentencing.
Leibell, a Republican, had been elected Putnam County executive a month before his guilty plea. He gave up that post as well as the last month of his Senate term.
He admitted he filed false tax returns for 2003 through 2006. Leibell spent 12 years in the Assembly before his 16 years in the Senate. The felony convictions don't affect his public pension, estimated at about $70,000 a year."
The Chief Justice Thinks Death Row Briefing is "Perverse," Imagine that?!
Nathan Gorenstein at Philly.com has the story of a honked-off Pa. Supreme Court Chief Justice. This is an excerpt from Gorenstein's story about the death row appeal of Mark Spotz:
"After reading the appeal from prison inmate Mark Spotz, incarcerated on four murder convictions, an angry Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille (pic) unleashed perhaps the most scathing language ever from the Pennsylvania State Supreme Court. His target was not the killer; it was the highly specialized Capital Habeas Unit, 35 mostly federally funded defense lawyers who handle death-case appeals and whom Castille accused of legal 'sabotage.'.[ . . . ]
To Castille, the massive legal document, and the government-funded work it represented, 'bordered on the perverse.' It was an example, he wrote last month, of federal defense attorneys using an intentionally 'abusive' strategy intended 'exhaust as much of this court's time and resources as possible' and frustrate the legitimate exercise of the death penalty.
[The Chief Justice] called it, 'The zealous pursuit of what is difficult to view as anything but a political cause: to impede and sabotage the death penalty in Pennsylvania.'
On Friday, the federal defenders responded with their own lengthy written blast, calling the former Philadelphia district attorney's accusations 'unwarranted" and "unfounded.' They also denied a 'suggestion' from Castille that using federal lawyers in state courts was a misuse of federal money.
Behind the unusual dispute is the fact that, although the death penalty is on the books, it is not used in Pennsylvania. There are 215 people on death row in the state, but no one has been involuntarily executed in about three decades. The last execution was in 1999, when torture-murderer Gary Heidnik voluntarily halted his appeals.
Long-running litigation in death-penalty cases has long angered prosecutors and some victims' relatives - particularly the spouses of police officers killed on duty - even as law enforcement officials concede there is a need for review. Most of the cases on appeal are more than a decade old, as Pennsylvania juries have become more reluctant to impose death in first-degree murder cases.
The federal defenders say they are merely doing what they are paid to do: provide the best representation possible. They cannot choose who deserves the best effort, said Leigh M. Skipper, the chief federal defender based in Philadelphia. 'We take the cases as we find them. We can't differentiate between 'good murderers' and 'bad murderers.' A lawyer has an ethical obligation.'
The lawyers also sharply rejected Castille's complaints that they nitpick to deliberately clog the court.
'As a lawyer who is appointed to represent someone, we don't have the luxury of saying, 'Well, it's close; we don't make this argument,' ' said David Rudovsky, president of the Defender Association of Philadelphia, which oversees public defenders in state and federal courts. 'Frivolous claims are in the eye of the beholder,' he said."
______________________
What's perverse is the false allure of the death penalty as a path to justice.
Chief Justice Castille is drunk on his own spiked-Koolaid. Perhaps he's forgetting the ethical obligation of lawyers to zealously represent their client, perhaps even save a human life, loathsome as that might seem.
"After reading the appeal from prison inmate Mark Spotz, incarcerated on four murder convictions, an angry Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille (pic) unleashed perhaps the most scathing language ever from the Pennsylvania State Supreme Court. His target was not the killer; it was the highly specialized Capital Habeas Unit, 35 mostly federally funded defense lawyers who handle death-case appeals and whom Castille accused of legal 'sabotage.'.[ . . . ]
To Castille, the massive legal document, and the government-funded work it represented, 'bordered on the perverse.' It was an example, he wrote last month, of federal defense attorneys using an intentionally 'abusive' strategy intended 'exhaust as much of this court's time and resources as possible' and frustrate the legitimate exercise of the death penalty.
[The Chief Justice] called it, 'The zealous pursuit of what is difficult to view as anything but a political cause: to impede and sabotage the death penalty in Pennsylvania.'
On Friday, the federal defenders responded with their own lengthy written blast, calling the former Philadelphia district attorney's accusations 'unwarranted" and "unfounded.' They also denied a 'suggestion' from Castille that using federal lawyers in state courts was a misuse of federal money.
Behind the unusual dispute is the fact that, although the death penalty is on the books, it is not used in Pennsylvania. There are 215 people on death row in the state, but no one has been involuntarily executed in about three decades. The last execution was in 1999, when torture-murderer Gary Heidnik voluntarily halted his appeals.
Long-running litigation in death-penalty cases has long angered prosecutors and some victims' relatives - particularly the spouses of police officers killed on duty - even as law enforcement officials concede there is a need for review. Most of the cases on appeal are more than a decade old, as Pennsylvania juries have become more reluctant to impose death in first-degree murder cases.
The federal defenders say they are merely doing what they are paid to do: provide the best representation possible. They cannot choose who deserves the best effort, said Leigh M. Skipper, the chief federal defender based in Philadelphia. 'We take the cases as we find them. We can't differentiate between 'good murderers' and 'bad murderers.' A lawyer has an ethical obligation.'
The lawyers also sharply rejected Castille's complaints that they nitpick to deliberately clog the court.
'As a lawyer who is appointed to represent someone, we don't have the luxury of saying, 'Well, it's close; we don't make this argument,' ' said David Rudovsky, president of the Defender Association of Philadelphia, which oversees public defenders in state and federal courts. 'Frivolous claims are in the eye of the beholder,' he said."
______________________
What's perverse is the false allure of the death penalty as a path to justice.
Chief Justice Castille is drunk on his own spiked-Koolaid. Perhaps he's forgetting the ethical obligation of lawyers to zealously represent their client, perhaps even save a human life, loathsome as that might seem.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








