Friday, July 30, 2010

New Jersey "Boorish" Lawyer

The invaluable Legal Profession blawg reports on the opinion of the NJ Supreme Court suspending a lawyer for one year.  NJ must be a pretty tolerant state, because this guy has had several go rounds with the authorities in the past, mostly relating to client communication problems. 

David Witherspoon's client communication problems now include soliciting sex from his clients in exchange for proposed discounts on attorney fees or as the NJ Supreme Court calls it "attempted sexual bartering."  Mike Frisch at Legal Profession summarizes as follows:

The . . . charges involved allegations that [Witherspoon] offered discounted legal services or refunds to three female clients and the daughter of a fourth client 'in the context of suggestions that they perform certain acts with him or with other women while he watched.' He told one lesbian client that her lesbianism was caused 'by a bad experience with the male sexual organ,' that she was 'looking good,' and that he 'would return $600 of fees she had paid him if she joined him on the office couch.' He claimed that these and other similar comments were made in jest.

The attorney's explanation was rejected by a district ethics committee and the Disciplinary Review Board. The DRB proposed a three-month suspension with two dissenters favoring a six-month sit down. The court here took a sterner view, although the court majority concluded that disbarment was 'disproportionate...for his boorish, insensitive and offensive, but hardly criminal, conduct.'
Justice LaVecchia, joined by Justice Albin, would disbar: 'A zero-tolerance policy toward attorneys who prey on clients, whether financially or as [he] has done, is needed to protect the public and the reputation of the profession.'"
You know where the Bad Lawyer comes down on the exploitation of clients.  Clients are vulnerable and easy prey, the lawyer/predator is not fit to practice law.


  1. I'm glad they clarified their view on that pesky discount issue.

  2. he was also my lawyer and was talking abt how he'd be with me if i was older and questioned me on how come i didn't meet mr. right.

  3. I went to his office one day at his office in newark nj to file for bankruptcy when he heard that i didnt have enough to pay him, he told me the he would knock off some money if i gave him a lap dance & that my figure was excited him and that my husband was lucky. Then he said that if i had sex with him that i would only have to pay a couple hundred. I got the hell out of there as fast as i could. Then he called my phone saying that he would do the work pro bono. I never replied. Hes a f$@$ing creepy preditor.

  4. Here is an attorney practicing law in New Jersey with over 25 years of experience representing clients. NJ Attorney

  5. Thank you for your great article.Law is a system of rules that are enforced through social institutions to govern behaviour. Laws can be made by legislatures through legislation.
    NJ Lawyer

  6. Thank you for the valuable info :) DUI is considered as a criminal offence in New Jersey. And to deal with it properly, you will need an experienced DUI lawyer in NJ . Contact Stabile Law Firm now to get the one!